4 Best Hotels in Old Town, Edinburgh and the Lothians

Background Illustration for Hotels

The narrow pends (alleys), cobbled streets, and steep hills of the Old Town remind you that this is a city with many layers of history. From medieval to modernist, these hotels all are within a stone's throw of the action.

THE BEST HOTEL IN OLD TOWN

The Witchery by the Castle

$$$$ | 352 Castlehill, Edinburgh, EH1 2NF, Scotland

FODOR’S EXPERT REVIEW

The word “magical” is often thrown around, but The Witchery truly casts a spell. From the approach up the historic Royal Mile, where the medieval stone buildings emerge from the mist alongside their iconic neighbor, Edinburgh Castle, to the almost outrageously romantic rooms, this property is bathed in dark magic. Nestled in the heart of Edinburgh, the shadowy history of the site extends back to the witch trials of the 16th century and includes many monarchy-adjacent stories. In its modern incarnation, they are perhaps best known for their two excellent restaurants–The Witchery and The Secret Garden–while an adjacent building houses their nine luxurious rooms. This arrangement adds to the unique and intimate quality of a stay here. It feels less like a hotel and more like you are hiding out in the tower of a secret castle, sheltering from that moody Scottish weather. It's a truly immersive experience. 

Pros

  • Wildly romantic rooms with incredible bathrooms
  • Iconic location beside Edinburgh Castle
  • Excellent dining in atmospheric restaurants

Cons

  • No bar or lobby area in which to linger
  • No spa or fitness facilities
  • Steep spiral staircases are challenging for those with mobility issues
352 Castlehill, Edinburgh, EH1 2NF, Scotland
0131-225–5613
Hotel Details
9 suites
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Hotel du Vin

$$$ | 11 Bristo Pl., Edinburgh, EH1 1EZ, Scotland
Hotel Du Vin, Old Town
Courtesy of Hotel Du Vin

Leave it to one of the United Kingdom's most forward-thinking hotel chains to convert a Victorian-era asylum into this understated luxury property, which combines a real sense of history with contemporary decor and trappings. The 47 amply proportioned rooms are all individually designed, though you'll find each combines original architectural elements with modern conveniences. There's also French-style Bistro du Vin, a mezzanine bar, a cigar area, a well-stocked wine cellar, and a whisky snug, where 270 different varieties of the "water of life" are ripe for sampling. It may have a brutal history, but today it's a great place to relax in the heart of the city.

Pros

  • Unique and historic building
  • Sunny courtyard
  • Lively on-site dining and drinking

Cons

  • Dated decor
  • Neighborhood can be noisy
  • Service can be hit-and-miss
11 Bristo Pl., Edinburgh, EH1 1EZ, Scotland
0131-285–1479
Hotel Details
47 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Cheval Old Town Chambers

$$$ | 329 High St., Edinburgh, EH1 1PN, Scotland

Just a few steps down from the Royal Mile, Cheval Old Town Chambers offers all the space and flexibility of luxury apartments, but with hotel-style amenities like a 24-hour reception, a concierge desk, and a free on-site gym (with personal trainer). Apartments come in all shapes and sizes, from open-plan studios, through one- and two-bedroom apartments, all the way up to the jaw-dropping three-bedroom penthouse. Each is individually designed, but expect colorful and modern furnishings, smart TVs, and fully equipped kitchens (including dishwashers).

Pros

  • Spectacular three-bedroom penthouse suite
  • Spacious apartments
  • Gorgeous artwork by local photographer

Cons

  • No air-conditioning in older building
  • No room service or phone
  • Lots of steps
329 High St., Edinburgh, EH1 1PN, Scotland
0131-510–5499
Hotel Details
75 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

The Knight Residence

$$$ | 12 Lauriston St., Edinburgh, EH3 9DJ, Scotland

Situated just around the corner from Grassmarket, these spacious serviced apartments offer a great base for exploring the city center by foot. There's everything from one- to three-bedroom apartments, all with comfortable bedrooms, spacious living and dining rooms, modern bathrooms, and fully outfitted kitchens that include laundry machines and dishwashers. The decor is simple but stylish, if a little business hotel-like.

Pros

  • Ultra-convenient central location
  • Spacious rooms with comfy beds
  • Secure parking available (at a cost)

Cons

  • Wi-Fi could be stronger
  • Lots of street noise when windows are open
  • Some areas need refurbishment
12 Lauriston St., Edinburgh, EH3 9DJ, Scotland
0800-304--7160
Hotel Details
28 apartments
No Meals

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Not finding what you're looking for?

We've got a few suggestions for nearby spots.
$$$ New Town

Cheval The Edinburgh Grand0.4 miles away

42 St. Andrew Sq., Edinburgh, Edinburgh, EH2 2AD, Scotland
We recommend 2 Hotels in New Town
$$$$ New Town

InterContinental Edinburgh The George0.5 miles away

19--21 George St., Edinburgh, Edinburgh, EH2 2PB, Scotland
We recommend 2 Hotels in New Town
$$$$ West End

Waldorf Astoria Edinburgh—The Caledonian0.8 miles away

Princes St., Edinburgh, Edinburgh, EH1 2AB, Scotland
We recommend 3 Hotels in West End
$$ West End

Rutland Hotel0.8 miles away

1–3 Rutland St., Edinburgh, Edinburgh, EH1 2AE, Scotland
We recommend 3 Hotels in West End
$$$ West End

B+B Edinburgh1.1 miles away

3 Rothesay Terr., Edinburgh, Edinburgh, EH3 7RY, Scotland
We recommend 3 Hotels in West End