2 Best Hotels in Eureka, The North Coast

Background Illustration for Hotels

We've compiled the best of the best in Eureka - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Carter House Inns

$ | 301 L St., Eureka, CA, 95501, USA Fodor's Choice

Richly painted and aglow with wood detailing, the inns' guest rooms, in two main Victorian buildings and several historic cottages, contain a mix of modern and antique furnishings. For dinner, Restaurant 301 is right on the property, and the hotel is a short walk from other good dining options. Whether it's breakfast in bed or an in-room massage, guests' requests are usually accommodated.

Pros

  • Elegant ambience
  • Whirlpool tubs and separate sitting areas in some rooms
  • Superb Restaurant 301

Cons

  • Not suitable for children
  • Restaurant a bit pricey
  • Two-night minimum on weekends
301 L St., Eureka, CA, 95501, USA
707-444–8062
Hotel Details
33 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Inn at 2nd and C

$ | 139 2nd St., Eureka, CA, 95501, USA

By the bustling waterfront and steps from Old Town's inviting shops and restaurants, this towering, late-1880s Victorian abounds with opulent architectural details and florid period-style bedding, wallpapers, and furnishings. It's a rambling, quirky place, but upgraded amenities, fair rates, a great location, and historical character make it a solid choice. There's a lively and charming pub on the ground floor, Phatsy Kline's, and the Tavern restaurant serves contemporary California cuisine.

Pros

  • Upgraded amenities
  • Tavern restaurant and Phatsy Kline's pub
  • Reasonable rates

Cons

  • Thin walls
  • Least expensive rooms are small
  • Rambling, quirky place
139 2nd St., Eureka, CA, 95501, USA
707-444–3344
Hotel Details
23 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Not finding what you're looking for?

We've got a few suggestions for nearby spots.
$ Trinidad

Trinidad Inn20.3 miles away

1170 Patricks Point Dr., Trinidad, California, 95570, USA
We recommend 3 Hotels in Trinidad
$ Avenue of the Giants

Scotia Lodge21.1 miles away

100 Main St., Scotia, California, 95565, USA
We recommend 1 Hotels in Avenue of the Giants
$$ Trinidad

Turtle Rocks Oceanfront Inn23.2 miles away

3392 Patricks Point Dr., Trinidad, California, 95570, USA
We recommend 3 Hotels in Trinidad
$$ Trinidad

Lost Whale Inn23.2 miles away

3452 Patricks Point Dr., Trinidad, California, 95570, USA
We recommend 3 Hotels in Trinidad
$$$$ Fort Bragg Fodor's Choice

The Inn at Newport Ranch85.9 miles away

31502 N. Hwy. 1, Fort Bragg, California, 95437, USA
We recommend 3 Hotels in Fort Bragg