2 Best Bars in Bay Shore, Long Island

Background Illustration for Nightlife

We've compiled the best of the best in Bay Shore - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

The Cortland

This tiny establishment is one of the coolest little hole-in-the-wall places you'll find in the area. Popular among the young hipster crowd, it’s the place to enjoy craft beers, creative cocktails, and infusions like hop-infused vodka. Fun events include live-music, trivia, and art nights.

27 W. Main St., Bay Shore, NY, 11706, USA
631-206–2220

Something incorrect in this review?

T.J. Finley's

Beer-geeks unite! This packed bar offers a dizzying array—usually more than 80—of local and import varieties, including cask ales, and has its own beer club. A menu of pub grub, barbecue, sandwiches, and salads is offered to accompany its brews.

42 E. Main St., Bay Shore, NY, 11706, USA
631-647–4856

Something incorrect in this review?

Not finding what you're looking for?

We've got a few suggestions for nearby spots.
Fire Island

Sandbar6.8 miles away

470 Bay Walk, Fire Island, New York, 11770, USA
We recommend 5 Nightlife in Fire Island
Fire Island

Flynn's7.6 miles away

Cayuga St., Fire Island, New York, 11706, USA
We recommend 5 Nightlife in Fire Island
Fire Island

Ice Palace9.3 miles away

1 Dock Walk, Fire Island, New York, 11782, USA
We recommend 5 Nightlife in Fire Island
Fire Island

Cherry's on the Bay9.3 miles away

158 Bayview Walk, Fire Island, New York, 11707, USA
We recommend 5 Nightlife in Fire Island
Fire Island

Casino Bar13 miles away

Trustee Walk, Fire Island, New York, 11772, USA
We recommend 5 Nightlife in Fire Island