3 Best Restaurants in Long Beach, Long Island

Background Illustration for Restaurants

We've compiled the best of the best in Long Beach - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Pancho's Cantina

$$$ Fodor's Choice

This place has been selling tacos on Long Island for more than two decades, so when Hurricane Sandy destroyed the restaurant in October 2012 a hole was left in the Long Beach/Island Park community. Now this family-friendly restaurant, known for consistently outgoing service, good Tex-Mex food, margaritas, and pitchers of delicious sangria, is back and as good as ever. Brown paper covers the tables, and if your artwork is good enough, it may end up on the wall. Garlic lovers should try the shrimp maragrita entree or the cattleman's steak drenched in homemade garlic BBQ sauce. Fajitas and fish tacos are perennial favorites.

Jimmy Hays Steak House

$$$$

Great steaks are the draw at this elegantly upbeat restaurant, and though a meal here doesn't come cheap, fans return for the perfectly prepared food and impeccable service, starting with valet parking that rivals that of New York City's best steakhouse. Favorite main dishes include Black Angus rib eye paired with sautéed spinach and a potato pancake, and Lobster Jimmy (pan-sautéed lobster with lemon, butter, and garlic). For poultry fans, the Tuscan chicken is a flavorful choice. Dessert options include chocolate mousse, peach melba, or crème brûlée. The restaurant is about a five-minute drive from Long Beach.

If you plan to share, be prepared for an $8 sharing charge.

Long Beach Bagel Café

$

So much more than breakfast, this bagel store offers a mind-boggling array of out-of-the-ordinary salads including Thai chicken salad, Buffalo chicken, taco chicken, balsamic or honey-mustard tuna, egg salad with caramelized onion and mushroom, as well as cream cheese flavors like sundried tomato–jalapeño, chocolate chip, and apple-walnut-raisin. Be prepared to wait on a long line, especially on weekends.

Recommended Fodor's Video

Not finding what you're looking for?

We've got a few suggestions for nearby spots.
$$ Garden City

Seventh Street Cafe9.5 miles away

Italian
126 7th St., Garden City, New York, 11530, USA
We recommend 3 Restaurants in Garden City
$$ Garden City

Orchid9.5 miles away

Chinese
730 Franklin Ave., Garden City, New York, 11530, USA
We recommend 3 Restaurants in Garden City
$$ Garden City

Akbar10.7 miles away

Indian
1 Ring Rd. W, Garden City, New York, 11530, USA
We recommend 3 Restaurants in Garden City
$$$$ Great Neck

Peter Luger Steak House13.4 miles away

Steak House
255 Northern Blvd., Great Neck, New York, 11021, USA
We recommend 3 Restaurants in Great Neck
$$$$ Great Neck

La Coquille Manhasset14.2 miles away

French
1669 Northern Blvd., Manhasset, New York, 11030, USA
We recommend 3 Restaurants in Great Neck