5 Best Restaurants in Rochester, The Finger Lakes

Background Illustration for Restaurants

A spate of economical chain hotels can be found near the airport and in Henrietta, a southern suburb with big-box stores and a mall.

The Glen Iris

$

A wraparound porch overlooks the gorge and a waterfall at this restaurant within Letchworth State Park. American and European fare on the seasonal menu might include entrées such as chicken breast over spinach fettuccine in a garlic-cream sauce, salmon with a barbecue maple glaze cooked on a cedar plank, and slow-roasted prime rib with fresh horseradish. The dining room is in keeping with the Victorian style of inn; large windows take in the park setting.

7 Letchworth State Park, Castile, NY, 14427, USA
585-493--2622
Restaurant Details
Credit cards accepted

Something incorrect in this review?

The Hideaway

$$

The clientele—from suit-wearing execs to hoodie-clad students—is as varied as the menu at this pubby restaurant with wooden booths and brick walls. Specials fill five 4-foot-square blackboards, change daily, and feature many fish dishes, such as basil-pesto-crusted salmon fillet. The regular menu includes sandwiches and soups, which make for a cheap but filling meal. Diners spill onto a patio in summer.

197 Park Ave., Rochester, NY, 14607, USA
585-434--0511
Restaurant Details
Credit cards accepted
Reservations not accepted

Something incorrect in this review?

Mr. Dominic's

$

The family-run Italian restaurant, a staple in Charlotte since the mid-1970s, draws a loyal clientele from throughout the city. Homemade pastas—gnocchi, lasagna, veal and lobster ravioli, four-cheese manicotti—are a specialty, but then again so are the steaks, chops, and seafood. It's two blocks from Lake Ontario, which makes it especially busy in summer.

4699 Lake Ave., Rochester, NY, 14612, USA
585-730--5444
Restaurant Details
Credit cards accepted
No lunch Sat.--Mon.

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Schaller's Drive-In

$

Opened in 1956, the family-owned and -operated restaurant has retained a Happy Days feel. Place your order and the cashier yells it out amid the din. Burgers topped with Schaller's secret hot sauce are the most popular choice, followed by a Rochester specialty, white hot dogs, also known as "white hots" (sausage-size, natural-casing dogs made with pork, beef, and veal). The restaurant, west of Ontario Beach Park in the town of Greece, is particularly popular with the beach crowd. Take out on a sunny day or eat in the bright dining room.

965 Edgemere Dr., Greece, NY, 14612, USA
585-865--3319
Restaurant Details
No credit cards
Reservations not accepted

Something incorrect in this review?

Tapas 177

$

Spanish-style appetizers and entrées draw from Latin and European roots, as does the music and decor, at this below-street-level restaurant. The decor, with candlelight, brick arches, and curtained-off cubbyhole seating is Morocco-meets-Paris, and the menu, which changes weekly, highlights seafood, with options for vegetarians well as carnivores. You might choose from chicken empanadas or Thai-glazed barbecued ribs (on the tapas menu) or wasabi-pea-encrusted tuna or guava-chipotle beef fillet (among the main dishes). A full martini menu includes chocolate, melon, lemon, and orange varieties. The specialty dessert—bananas wrapped in a fried, cinnamon-and-sugar-covered tortilla—is always available.

177 Saint Paul St., Rochester, NY, 14604, USA
585-262--2090
Restaurant Details
Credit cards accepted

Something incorrect in this review?

Not finding what you're looking for?

We've got a few suggestions for nearby spots.
$$ Canandaigua

Eric's Office23.7 miles away

American
2574 County Rd. 28, Canandaigua, New York, 14424, USA
We recommend 2 Restaurants in Canandaigua
$$ Canandaigua

Casa de Pasta25.1 miles away

Italian
125 Bemis St., Canandaigua, New York, 14424, USA
We recommend 2 Restaurants in Canandaigua
$ Geneva

The Cobblestone Restaurant37 miles away

European
3610 Pre Emption Rd., Geneva, New York, 14456, USA
We recommend 2 Restaurants in Geneva
$$ Geneva

Ports Cafe38.8 miles away

Eclectic
​4432 West Lake Rd., Geneva, New York, 14456, USA
We recommend 2 Restaurants in Geneva
$ Seneca Falls

Connie's Diner42.1 miles away

American
205 E. Main St., Waterloo, New York, 13165, USA
We recommend 2 Restaurants in Seneca Falls