4 Best Restaurants in Bainbridge Island, The Puget Sound Islands

A great place to grab a cup of coffee and a snack before exploring the island, Blackbird serves rich pastries and cakes along with quiche, soups, and a good selection of teas and espresso drinks. Though there is some nice window seating that allows you to watch the human parade on Winslow Way, the place gets very crowded, especially when the ferries come in, so you might want to take your order to go.

An 1881 estate home overlooking Eagle Harbor was renovated to create this casual pub and restaurant at Winslow's Harbor Marina, where a complimentary boat tie-up is available for pub patrons. Local seafood—including steamed mussels, clams, and oyster chowder—plus burgers and poutine are typical fare, and there are 13 beers on tap. This is where the kayaking and pleasure-boating crowds come to dine in a relaxed, waterfront setting. When the sun shines, the harbor-front deck is the place to be.

Pegasus is a Bainbridge Island fixture with all the best coffeehouse characteristics: a crackling fire, cozy seating, fresh java, and a clientele of artsy locals. The charming ivy-covered brick building is the original location for longtime roaster Pegasus, which is sold all over the region. Accompany your coffee with a delicious pastry, sandwich, avocado toast, or bagel with smoked salmon. Or indulge in an affogato or cold brew float for a late afternoon treat.

It may be a no-frills diner, but Streamliner is a local institution on Bainbridge Island thanks to its hearty breakfasts and vegetarian options. Many travelers stop for a bite here when they hop off the ferry, though you'll see just as many locals lining up for breakfast and lunch. Waits can be long during the busy season, but you can explore the nearby shops until your table is ready.