3 Best Hotels in Coromandel and the Bay of Plenty, New Zealand

Background Illustration for Hotels

Like mellow places around the world, you'll find plenty of comfortable bed-and-breakfasts and stylish motels, but both Coromandel and Bay of Plenty also have a sprinkling of luxe boutique lodges tucked away in the forest or along coastal coves. In peak season, from October through March, advance booking is essential across the board and many of the better places have long-term customers who book as much as a year in advance.

Matahui Lodge

$$$$ | 187 Matahui Rd., Katikati, 3178, New Zealand Fodor's Choice

This lodge on 6 acres of manicured gardens and vineyards is an outstanding example of the boutique home-hosted properties in this region. There are two suites, the Merlot Room (private balcony, en suite with double shower) and the Cabernet Suite (large patio with hot tub, en suite with double shower). Both have a complimentary minibar, big windows, and grand views. You could putter on the driving range, work-out in the gym, enjoy the hot tub, or order up a massage. Breakfast is included, while an optional dinner is worth staying in for; don't forget to take advantage of the excellent wine cellar.

Pros

  • Substantial breakfasts
  • Lovely gardens
  • Good wine list

Cons

  • A little far from town for some
  • Some rooms have stair access
  • Books up quickly
187 Matahui Rd., Katikati, 3178, New Zealand
07-571–8121
Hotel Details
2 suites
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Grand Mercure Puka Park Resort

$$$$ | 32 Mount Ave., Pauanui, 3546, New Zealand

This hillside hideaway, managed by the international Accor hotel chain, is nestled in native bushland near Pauanui Beach. Timber chalets are furnished with a designer's flair. Sliding glass doors lead to a balcony perched among the treetops. Miha Restaurant, with its elegant interior or casual alfresco spaces, describes its menu as Pacific Rim with a modern European twist. Guest facilities include a swimming pool, hot tub, gym, and tennis court. They have bikes for rent and there's an international 18-hole golf course down the road.

Pros

  • Upscale and well-appointed
  • Close to the beach
  • Pool, tennis court, and bikes are among amenities

Cons

  • Somewhat formal for the region
  • Access to rooms not easy on steep paths (call for a golf cart)
  • Steep climb uphill from the beach
32 Mount Ave., Pauanui, 3546, New Zealand
07-864–8088
Hotel Details
42 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Orokawa Bay Retreat

$$$$ | 28 Poet's Corner Rd., Waihi, 3681, New Zealand

Located on top of a hill, this four bedroom retreat has panoramic views of the ocean and countryside. Mount Maunganui can be seen down the coast and White Island directly offshore. Guests have exclusive use of the retreat, no matter whether you book one or all four of the rooms. A spacious open-plan living, dining, and kitchen area opens up through bi-fold doors to a patio area with superb views from the comfortable outdoor furniture. There's a hot tub, positioned to take advantage of sea views, and local artwork is showcased throughout. Hosts Mike and Sheryl live offsite, but personally welcome guests and are happy to arrange massages, beauty treatments, or personal chefs. 

Pros

  • Hot tub with a view
  • Front patio area is perfectly positioned for watching sunrise
  • Fully equipped laundry room

Cons

  • Neighbors' driveway runs right in front of patio area
  • 15-minute drive to restaurants
  • Out-of-the-way location up a narrow rural road
28 Poet's Corner Rd., Waihi, 3681, New Zealand
021-272–0833
Hotel Details
4 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video