20 Best Restaurants in Central Sicily and the Mediterranean Coast, Sicily

In the sleepy town of Santa Rita, you'll find a culinary gem worth the drive off the beaten path. Driving along narrow roads that may be filled with sheep herders, you'll get to Forno Santa Rita, a bakery managed by a father-and-son team who mill regional wheat to make the most delicate focaccia you'll ever taste. They also make pasta from the same organic semolina, which you can buy pre-packaged at their little shop along with other products like sauces, beers, and jams from the area. The bakery has a small dining room and a terrace. It's popular, especially on the weekends, so reservations are a must (send a text or call on WhatsApp). 

One of the most famous restaurants in Sicily—and one of only two on the island to have been awarded a second Michelin star—La Madia is a must-visit when you're here. Chef Pino Cuttaio is a legend within Sicily and beyond thanks to his incredible talent for creating unique dishes that fuse tradition and innovation, without ever losing sight of the kind of simplicity that allows the brilliance and flavors of first-rate Sicilian produce to shine. There are three tasting menus, inspired by the che's vision. Advance reservations are required.

This wholesaler specializes in oysters, mollusks, and crustaceans, and offers a tasting room that has become an obligatory stop for seafood aficionados in town. This may look like nothing but a fish market, but diners are dazzled by the quality of the seafood. There are 24 kinds of oysters, all manner of clams (including Galician percebes), local red prawns in several sizes, and a tank of lobsters and crabs as well as fresh seasonal tuna. Choose between having your fish raw, steamed, grilled, or a la gratin, and dine in the simple blue and white conservatory while enjoying a glass or two of local white wine. You can also get a fine fish couscous (one portion is ample for two people). 

This culinary beacon in Sicily's interior features ambitious—and successful—dishes with the creative flair of chef Angelo Treno, whose unforgettable pastas topped with truffles or caviar, for example, offer a decidedly different expression of traditional regional ingredients. The unassuming and elegant dining room is inside an old railway house and is the perfect place to enjoy a bottle from the 500-label wine list; in cold weather, you can cozy up to a fireplace, but the terrace is the place to be in summer.

Although Bar Corso is open for 20 continuous hours daily, the highlight is breakfast. This bustling café is filled with locals and tourists having their morning coffee with freshly made breads and pastries. The counter is filled with regional pastries like cucchitelle, a traditional pastry made with almond flour. Those with a savory palate will enjoy the bread made with semolina flour and filled with ham and cheese. Although the inside space is compact, there's a large outdoor seating area where you can people-watch. 

The restaurant in the graceful winter garden of Relais Briuccia's is simply one of the finest restaurants in Sicily and offers an utterly unique dining experience. Chef-owner Damiano Ferraro is endlessly creative, spinning his magic daily with the freshest of local Sicilian produce. Ferraro is a local who dreamed big and has worked all over the world (including at the Dorchester in London and with the Roux Brothers at La Gavroche); he then returned home and created this small-town gastronomic paradise. There are both tasting and à la carte menus. Although more expensive than those at other restaurants in the area, the tasting menus here offer a much more elevated and special dining experience that is well worth the additional cash.

Agrigento's finest ice-cream parlor creates memorable versions of key Sicilian favorites such as pistachio, almond, and cassata, along with a superb "pecorino" made with fresh sheep's milk ricotta. Besides the famous gelato, there's a great selection of pastries, the most popular being the cannoli. Those looking to cool down can order a cocktail and take in the view of the city from the terrace. 

This eatery has minimalist decor and young owners who are committed to local produce—right down to listing all producers on their website—without being scared to experiment. The wine list is really interesting, focusing mainly on small Sicilian bottles, and there is also a good selection of artisanal beer.

The concept of a "home restaurant," where people set up small restaurants in their homes, is becoming increasingly popular in Sicily. A five-minute car ride from Scala dei Turchi, you'll find "A Casa di Donatella," a tiny dining room inside the home of Donatella, a passionate home cook. Don't expect fine dining, but rather a warm home environment where you'll sample hearty homemade pastas and fresh seafood. If you're looking for an affordable and unique experience, give it a try. Reservations are essential, so call ahead (via WhatsApp).

You might not expect to find an ultramodern place to dine within a few minutes' drive of Agrigento's ancient temples. Yet, this restaurant offers pleasing versions of Sicilian classics in a trendy, country-chic atmosphere (think moody lighting and funky geometric tile floors mixed with walls lined with old-fashioned crockery and cookware) and is popular with young locals. The thoughtful wine list offers reasonable prices on local wines and those from throughout Sicily. Weather permitting, dine on the terrace for outstanding temple views. You can make reservations online.

Kokalos pairs Sicilian cuisine with a picturesque view of the Valley of the Temples, especially at night. Fresh ingredients highlight traditional dishes like the outstanding tuna tartare or pistachio pesto pizza with fresh burrata. A terrace offers prime seating, but the glass-walled dining room is perfect for hot days or colder months. Although away from the city center, the restaurant offers ample parking. It's popular so make reservations.

La Bottega Ristorante may seem like a classic hotel restaurant on the surface, but it's a hidden gem inside the Relais Villa Giuliana. The menu, focusing on handmade pastas and local seafood, is excellent, made with refined ingredients and served in surprisingly generous portions. While the price is slightly above average for the area, you'll find the quality of the ingredients and service up to par. Don't miss the home-baked bread served with a selection of local olive oils; the wine list focuses on regional selections. 

Open since 1987, La Nicchia is a Pantelleria institution, occupying an old dammuso and serving typical island dishes made with carefully sourced island ingredients: typically potatoes, cherry tomatoes, capers, almonds, and fresh herbs married with seasonal vegetables, fresh fish, and other seafood. In summer there are tables under the lemon trees in a traditional walled Pantescan garden. They also do good pizza, while their offshoot next-door, Dispensa Pantesca, serves a selection of informal light dishes to take away or enjoy with a glass of wine on the roof of the dammuso for amazing sunset views.

Le Stranizze, the city's restaurant outpost of De Gregorio winery, is a haven for lovers of Sicilian food and wine. The upscale menu offers modern takes on traditional arancini made with squid ink and filled with calamari, or a heaping plate of homemade pasta topped with grated bottarga, the cured roe pouch, which is a mainstay of Sicilian cuisine. Oenophiles will love the wine selections from their winery on the city's outskirts. There's a wine for every taste, from a sparkling Grillo to a Nero D'Avola. The dining room is cozy and modern, with outdoor seating during the warmer months. 

Adjacent to the unspoiled Spiaga di Bovo Marina beach, you'll find this upscale beachfront restaurant with a view of the sea and an ample, stylish terrace for alfresco dining. Although off the beaten path, it's a true fine-dining experience with classic Sicilian ingredients like mussels and tuna with a global touch of wasabi or a gazpacho. Guests will find a tasting menu that changes daily depending on the season and market availability. If you're looking for a simpler dining experience, they also feature à la carte dishes like pasta and fried fish. You can make an online reservation (recommended).

Offering an upscale culinary journey in Caltanisetta, this restaurant's tasting menus offer modern takes on such popular Sicilian ingredients as tuna, eggplant, and squash, with delicate presentations often topped with truffles or caviar. This is not a fast experience, so set aside several hours and plan to relax and take in the gastronomic experience from classically trained chef Ester Giacchetto.

Set on a big square in Piazza Armerina that hosts the town’s weekly market, this is one of the very few pasticcerias that continue to make their own cornetti—light, delicious, and filled to order with custard cream, ricotta, jam, or chocolate. Other delights include iris (a deep-fried doughnut ball filled with chocolate) and krapfen (a doughnut ring filled with custard cream). There is a small covered terrace outside.

Highly recommended by locals, this classic restaurant can be found right in the center of Caltanissetta. Although the menu focuses on seafood dishes, including such classics as red shrimp and swordfish, there are several vegetarian options. The owner takes the time to explain the dishes, albeit in Italian, but she takes great pride in the offerings. Along with a full menu of antipasti, primi, and secondi, the restaurant also offers an ample list of regional wines.

People from all walks of life, from winemakers and hotel owners to local families, all speak with affection about this comfortable trattoria and its delicious Sicilian dishes. The menu is filled with wonderful pasta dishes with generous use of local ingredients like ricotta, pistachios, and fresh vegetables. It is also known for its lamb dishes and small outside terrace for summertime dining.

This refreshingly atypical spot raises simple Sicilian street food to new gastronomic heights. The exuberant owner, Rosario Umbriaco, has won national prizes for his arancini; try the version with two strata of rice and melted saffron Piacentino Ennese cheese to find out why. He also makes what may be the most divine cannoli in Sicily, frying the tubular wafer in olive oil, rather than lard, and filling to order with cool, fresh, just-sweetened ricotta and candied orange from Noto’s famous Caffè Sicilia. In summer there are tables outside.