3 Best Restaurants in San Gimignano, Tuscany

Background Illustration for Restaurants

We've compiled the best of the best in San Gimignano - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Cum Quibus

$$ Fodor's Choice

This is, without a doubt, one of the region's most creative restaurants—an intimate place with a menu that's Tuscan but not (its signature egg yolk starter is done with élan). Not a step is missed, and although it's possible to order à la carte, the tasting menu is also a good way to go. When it's warm, you can sit outside in an enclosed courtyard.

Via San Martino 17, San Gimignano, 53037, Italy
0577-943199
Known For
  • Courtyard dining in nice weather
  • Incorporation of non-Tuscan ingredients into Tuscan food
  • Amazing wine list with prices to suit all budgets
Restaurant Details
Closed Wed. and Thurs. and Jan. and Feb.

Something incorrect in this review?

La Vecchia Nicchia

$$

Wonderful wines pair beautifully with the tasty morsels served atop toasted bread, though if you want something more substantial than the delicious cheese plate, consider the soup of the day. This place is an oasis in a town overrun with day visitors; though it's still very much in the center, it's far from the madding crowds.

Via San Martino 12, San Gimignano, 53037, Italy
0577-573172
Known For
  • Wines by the bottle
  • Locally sourced ingredients
  • Genial hosts
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon.–Thurs.

Something incorrect in this review?

Osteria del Carcere

$$

Although it calls itself an osteria (tavern), this place much more resembles a wine bar, with a bill of fare that includes several different types of pâtés and a short list of seasonal soups and salads. The sampler of goat cheeses, which can be paired with local wines, should not be missed. Operatic arias tend to play softly in the background, and service is courteous.

Via del Castello 13, San Gimignano, 53037, Italy
0577-941905
Known For
  • Excellent chef--proprietor
  • Inventive dishes
  • Housed in a former jail
Restaurant Details
Closed Wed. and early Jan.–Mar. No lunch Thurs.

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video