The Best Hotel in Edinburgh and the Lothians, Scotland

Background Illustration for Hotels

From stylish boutique hotels to homey B&Bs, Edinburgh has a world-class array of accommodation options to suit every taste. Its status as one of Britain's most attractive and fascinating cities ensures a steady influx of visitors, but the wealth of overnight options means there's no need to compromise on where you stay. Grand old hotels are rightly renowned for their regal bearing and old-world charm, but if your tastes are a little more contemporary, the city's burgeoning contingent of chic-design hotels offers an equally alluring alternative. For those on a tighter budget, the town's B&Bs are the most likely choice. If you've previously found B&Bs to be restrictive, keep in mind that Scots are trusting people—many proprietors provide front-door keys and very few impose curfews.

Rooms are harder to find in August and September, when the Edinburgh International Festival and the Festival Fringe take place, so reserve at least three months in advance. B&Bs may prove trickier to find in the winter months (with the exception of Christmas and New Year), as this is when many proprietors choose to close up shop and go on vacation themselves.

THE BEST HOTEL IN EDINBURGH AND THE LOTHIANS

The Witchery by the Castle

$$$$ | 352 Castlehill, Edinburgh, EH1 2NF, Scotland

FODOR’S EXPERT REVIEW

The word “magical” is often thrown around, but The Witchery truly casts a spell. From the approach up the historic Royal Mile, where the medieval stone buildings emerge from the mist alongside their iconic neighbor, Edinburgh Castle, to the almost outrageously romantic rooms, this property is bathed in dark magic. Nestled in the heart of Edinburgh, the shadowy history of the site extends back to the witch trials of the 16th century and includes many monarchy-adjacent stories. In its modern incarnation, they are perhaps best known for their two excellent restaurants–The Witchery and The Secret Garden–while an adjacent building houses their nine luxurious rooms. This arrangement adds to the unique and intimate quality of a stay here. It feels less like a hotel and more like you are hiding out in the tower of a secret castle, sheltering from that moody Scottish weather. It's a truly immersive experience. 

Pros

  • Wildly romantic rooms with incredible bathrooms
  • Iconic location beside Edinburgh Castle
  • Excellent dining in atmospheric restaurants

Cons

  • No bar or lobby area in which to linger
  • No spa or fitness facilities
  • Steep spiral staircases are challenging for those with mobility issues
352 Castlehill, Edinburgh, EH1 2NF, Scotland
0131-225–5613
Hotel Details
9 suites
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?