7 Best Hotels in Big Island, Hawaii

Background Illustration for Hotels

Even among locals, there is an ongoing debate about which side of the Big Island is "better," so don't worry if you're having a tough time deciding where to stay. Our recommendation? Do both. Each side offers a different range of accommodations, restaurants, and activities.

Consider staying at one of the upscale resorts along the Kohala Coast or in a condo in Kailua-Kona for half of your trip. Then, shift gears and check into a romantic bed-and-breakfast on the Hamakua Coast, South Kona, Hilo, or near the volcano. If you've got children in tow, opt for a vacation home or a stay at one of the island’s many family-friendly hotels. On the west side, explore the island’s most pristine beaches or try some of the fine-dining restaurants; on the east side, hike through rain forests, witness majestic waterfalls, or go for a plate lunch.

Some locals like to say that the east is "more Hawaiian," but we argue that King Kamehameha himself made Kailua-Kona his final home during his sunset years. Another reason to try a bit of both: your budget. You can justify splurging on a stay at a Kohala Coast resort for a few nights because you'll spend the rest of your time paying one-third that rate at a cozy cottage in Volcano or a vacation rental on Alii Drive. And although food at the resorts is very expensive, you don't have to eat every meal there. Condos and vacation homes can be ideal for a family trip or for a group of friends looking to save money and live like kamaainas (local residents) for a week or two. Many of the homes also have private pools and hot tubs, lanai, ocean views, and more—you can go as budget or as high-end as you like.

If you choose a bed-and-breakfast, inn, or an out-of-the-way hotel, explain your expectations fully to the proprietor and ask plenty of questions before booking. Be clear about your travel and location needs. Some places require stays of two or three days.

Puakea Ranch

$$$ | 56-2864 Akoni Pule Hwy., Hawi, HI, 96719, USA Fodor's Choice
Puakea Ranch, Kohala Coast
Giselle Thompson

Four beautifully restored ranch houses and bungalows occupy this historic country estate in Hawi, where guests enjoy their own private swimming pools, horseback riding, round-the-clock concierge availability, and plenty of fresh fruit from the orchards. Listed on the State Historic Register, Puakea Ranch pays homage to the four generations of cowboys and plantation workers who once lived on the property. The two-bedroom Yoshi's House sleeps six and has ocean views from the lanai, plus a lava-rock swimming pool. Cowboy House is a three-bedroom former bunkhouse that sleeps six, while the Miles Away bungalow provides two bedrooms and its own private dipping pool. A large studio, James Cottage shares a swimming pool with Cowboy House and also has its own private hot tub. Decorated with local art depicting the property, each home has its own kitchen, barbecue grills, and washer-dryer. It's 15 minutes to the closest public beach, and just down the road from the artists' town of Hawi. It's one of the few properties on the Kohala Coast that can also be entirely booked for weddings and events. 

Pros

  • Charmingly decorated
  • Washer and dryer in each house
  • Private swimming pools

Cons

  • 15 minutes to the beach
  • Spotty cell-phone coverage
  • Sometimes windy
56-2864 Akoni Pule Hwy., Hawi, HI, 96719, USA
808-315–0805
Hotel Details
4 houses
No Meals

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Lava Lava Beach Club Cottages

$$$$ | 69-1081 Kuualii Pl., Waikoloa, HI, 96738, USA Fodor's Choice

Spend the day swimming at the beach just steps away from your private lanai and fall asleep to the sound of the ocean at one of four artfully decorated, one-room cottages on the sandy beach at Anaehoomalu Bay. These cottages are among the few beachfront rentals you will find anywhere on the island. It's a short stroll to the adjacent Lava Lava Beach Club bar/restaurant, which serves lunch and dinner daily. Ride your included cruiser bike in the morning to the nearby coffee shops at the Kings' Shops and Queens' MarketPlace.

Pros

  • One of the island's few beachfront rentals
  • Fully air-conditioned
  • Fun, Hawaii-themed decor

Cons

  • Beach is public, so there may be people in front of cottage
  • Quite expensive
  • Noise, music from nearby restaurant
69-1081 Kuualii Pl., Waikoloa, HI, 96738, USA
808-769–5282
Hotel Details
4 cottages
No Meals

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Hilltop Legacy Vacation Rental

$ | 57 Hina St., Hilo, HI, 96720, USA

Built in the 1930s by a Japanese doctor, this vintage home offers stunning views of downtown Hilo and the bay. The Zen garden on the grounds reveals three colossal stones weighing several tons each and installed by the home’s original owner. A total of four simply furnished rooms come with private baths, and two of the rooms offer panoramic bay views.

Pros

  • Close to downtown
  • Billiard table
  • Garden to relax in

Cons

  • Two of the four rooms don't have views
  • Kitchen is shared
  • Parking issues
57 Hina St., Hilo, HI, 96720, USA
808-896--2074
Hotel Details
4 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Silver Oaks Ranch

$$ | 73-4570 Mamalahoa Hwy., Kailua-Kona, HI, 96740, USA

Three private cottages set on a 10-acre working ranch afford total privacy, with a few more amenities than a vacation house or condo. Owners Mark and Amy drop off a welcome basket with breakfast goodies your first day, and there's a washer and dryer in each unit, an outdoor pool, and a hot tub. The ranch is great for animal lovers, as it is replete with sheep, friendly goats, and chickens throughout.

Pros

  • Washer and dryer in each cottage
  • Deck with ocean views
  • Great for animal lovers

Cons

  • Five-night minimum stay
  • Rural location
  • No online booking
73-4570 Mamalahoa Hwy., Kailua-Kona, HI, 96740, USA
808-325–2000
Hotel Details
3 cottages
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Volcano Mist Cottage

$$$$ | 11-3932 9th St., HI, 96785, USA

Both rustic and Zen, this magical cottage in the rain forest features cathedral ceilings, spruce walls, cork flooring, and amenities not usually found at Volcano vacation rentals, like bathrobes, a Bose home theater system, and Trek mountain bikes. The outdoor patio feels like a contemporary lodge, with an enormous stone fireplace to warm those cool Volcano nights.

Pros

  • Isolated and private cottage
  • Outdoor Jacuzzi tub
  • Upscale amenities

Cons

  • Not large enough for families
  • 45 minutes from downtown Hilo
  • Pricey for the area
11-3932 9th St., HI, 96785, USA
808-895–8359
Hotel Details
1 cottage
Free Breakfast
2-night minimum stay

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Volcano Teapot Cottage

$$ | 19-4041 Kilauea Rd., HI, 96785, USA

A near-perfect spot for couples seeking a romantic getaway in Volcano Village, this historical 1912 two-bedroom cottage evokes a vintage country feeling in keeping with the summer homes of the era. The claw-foot bathtub, hot tub, and fireplace add to the general coziness. Continental breakfast is included, and the restaurants of Volcano Village are nearby.

Pros

  • Near town restaurants
  • Fireplace and hot tub
  • Laundry facilities

Cons

  • Accommodates three people max
  • Can get cold at night
  • Books up fast
19-4041 Kilauea Rd., HI, 96785, USA
808-937–4976
Hotel Details
1 cottage
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Waimea Gardens Cottage

$$ | Waimea (Hawaii County), HI, 96743, USA

Surprisingly luxe yet cozy and quaint, the three charming country cottages and one suite at this historical Hawaiian homestead are surrounded by flowering private gardens and a backyard stream. One cottage (Kohala) and the Ohana Suite include a full kitchen, and the others (Waimea and the Garden Studio) a kitchenette. Each is stocked with provisions, including fresh farm eggs from the property, for a generous and hearty self-serve breakfast. All have beautiful hardwood floors. The Kohala Cottage features a luxury bath with whirlpool soaking tub, and the Garden Studio is equipped with a rain showerhead. The grounds are teeming with birds and plant life that will make you want to move in for good. Inquire for seasonal specials. The physical address is given out only after a confirmed reservation.

Pros

  • Charming, self-contained units
  • Lush, bird-filled grounds
  • Kitchens include food for breakfast

Cons

  • 50% deposit within two weeks of booking and payment in full six weeks before arrival
  • Only personal or bank checks accepted
  • Three-night minimum stay
Waimea (Hawaii County), HI, 96743, USA
808-885–8550
Hotel Details
4 units
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?