The Best Restaurant in Amagansett, Long Island

Background Illustration for Restaurants

We've compiled the best of the best in Amagansett - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Astro's Pizza and Felice's Ristorante

$$

Its facade is unassuming and interior unpretentious, but you can't go wrong with any of the pizzas or house specialties at this family-owned pizzeria-ristorante that has been around since 1971. The restaurant serves classic pasta dishes, including a variety of ravioli and gnocchi in addition to chicken, veal, steak, Italian specialties like picatta and francese, and local, fresh seafood. It is open year-round, and you can eat here until 3 am or later on summer Friday and Saturday nights. Try the grandma pie, and allow extra time—it's made with love. Reservations can be made on the website.