The Best Hotel in Fire Island, Long Island

Background Illustration for Hotels

We've compiled the best of the best in Fire Island - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Palms Hotel

$$$$ | 168 Cottage Walk, Fire Island, NY, 11770, USA

On arrival at this boutique hotel you are greeted by velvet ropes and a red carpet, because here everyone is a V.I.P. The hotel, with a main building and additional cottages and suites scattered around town, is about down-to-earth luxury and comforts like marshmallowy soft beds and fully-equipped kitchens. It's a hip scene without being "a scene." Perfect for family celebrations or a friends' weekend, many rooms can be configured to accommodate large parties—the presidential penthouse accomodates up to 10 people (reserve well in advance), and many outdoor seating areas include one bayside with barbecues and kayaks. Outdoor movies are screened.

Pros

  • Comfortable outdoor seating on the bay
  • Can accommodate large parties

Cons

  • Not all properties are on the water
  • Check-in may be at a different location
  • Late check-in time
  • Minimum two night stay
168 Cottage Walk, Fire Island, NY, 11770, USA
631-583–8870
Hotel Details
Closed Oct.–Apr.
42 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?