The Best Hotel in Shelter Island, Long Island

Background Illustration for Hotels

We've compiled the best of the best in Shelter Island - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Sunset Beach

$$$$ | 35 Shore Rd., Shelter Island, NY, 11965, USA

An international crowd has flocked to this trendy hotel ever since celebrity hotelier Andre Balazs (of Los Angeles's Chateau Marmont and SoHo's Mercer) opened it in the late 1990s. Each retro-style guest room has a sundeck that looks out over the parking lot to the water. The beachfront French bistro–style restaurant provides the best people-watching around, and a great place to relax with a cocktail and enjoy the lingering sunset.

Pros

  • Luxurious bedding
  • Bicycles for guests' use

Cons

  • Service can be slow during peak season
  • Three-night minimum on holiday weekends
35 Shore Rd., Shelter Island, NY, 11965, USA
631-749–2001
Hotel Details
Credit cards accepted
Closed mid-Sept.–mid–May
20 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?