The Best Restaurant in Shelter Island, Long Island

Background Illustration for Restaurants

We've compiled the best of the best in Shelter Island - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Vine Street Café

$$$$

Husband-and-wife team Terry and Lisa Harwood create casual but sophisticated dishes, and their staff provides exceptional service. Diners can savor daily specials and staples such as steak frites, miso-glazed salmon, and Montauk black bass. Simple yet elegant, the interior features pale walls, exposed beams, white tablecloths, and light streaming in through the large windows. In warm weather you can dine alfresco under tiki lights.

41 S. Ferry Rd., Shelter Island, NY, 11964, USA
631-749–3210
Restaurant Details
Credit cards accepted
Closed Tues. and Wed.
Reservations essential

Something incorrect in this review?