4 Best Hotels in Southampton, Long Island

Background Illustration for Hotels

We've compiled the best of the best in Southampton - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

A Butler's Manor

$$$$ | 244 N. Main St., Southampton, NY, 11968, USA

Be prepared to be spoiled silly at this gorgeous bed-and-breakfast owned by Christopher Allen, who worked as a butler before opening this with his wife Kimberly. Rooms are decorated to represent the estates the owner worked in. Home-cooked hot breakfast includes a frittata with vegetables from the garden and Kim's delicious banana-stuffed French toast.

Pros

  • Free ride to Southampton beaches
  • CD and iPod jack in room

Cons

  • No safes
  • Cannot accommodate children younger than 12
  • Three-night minimum on summer weekends
244 N. Main St., Southampton, NY, 11968, USA
631-283–8550
Hotel Details
Credit cards accepted
Closed Jan.–Mar.
5 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Easterner Motel

$$$$ | 639 Montauk Hwy., Southampton, NY, 11968, USA

On two acres in the Shinnecock Hills, 5 miles west of downtown Southampton, this unassuming motel offers efficiencies with full kitchens, contemporary furniture, and free Wi-Fi; a deluxe room can accommodate families. It also features a pool, tennis courts, basketball hoop, and barbecue area.

Pros

  • Very friendly and helpful owner

Cons

  • Too far to walk to town
639 Montauk Hwy., Southampton, NY, 11968, USA
631-283–9292
Hotel Details
Credit cards accepted
8 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Mainstay Inn

$$$$ | 579 Hill St., Southampton, NY, 11968, USA

Hospitality is the hallmark of this charming shingle-covered colonial inn, where every bedroom has antique cast-iron beds and country pine furniture. Each shabby-chic room also seems to be filled with yard upon yard of fabric: generous floral table covers and drapes, white duvets, and quilted spreads. From here it's a 15-minute walk to Southampton and a mile to a public beach.

Pros

  • Outdoor saltwater pool
  • Continental breakfast is included
  • Pets are not allowed but well-behaved children are

Cons

  • Not as glitzy as other B&amp
  • Bs
  • Two- or three-night minimum weekends in-season
  • Strict cancellation policies
579 Hill St., Southampton, NY, 11968, USA
631-283–4375
Hotel Details
Credit cards accepted
5 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Southampton Inn

$$$$ | 91 Hill St., Southampton, NY, 11968, USA

With a shuttle to the beach, lots of on-site activities, and a quick walk to Southampton's shops and restaurants, this modern inn ticks a lot of boxes. Rooms have contemporary country furniture and fittings and the beds have down comforters and lots of pillows. Outside, Adirondack chairs are scattered throughout the expansive, formally landscaped grounds that include a patio courtyard, a large outdoor pool, and tennis courts. For a fee, seasonal residents and locals can get a membership to use the recreational faciltities here.

Pros

  • Small playground and game room
  • Walking distance to town

Cons

  • Doesn't have the luxury feel of a B&amp
  • B
  • Restaurant and bar can be noisy at night
  • Nightly rate for kids older than 12 sharing parents' room is $49
91 Hill St., Southampton, NY, 11968, USA
631-283–6500
Hotel Details
Credit cards accepted
90 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?