3 Best Hotels in Hunter, The Catskills

Background Illustration for Hotels

We've compiled the best of the best in Hunter - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Hotel Mountain Brook

$$ | 57 Hill St., Tannersville, NY, 12485, USA Fodor's Choice

Originally constructed in the 1940s, this Adirondacks-style lodge has been thoroughly updated without losing any of its period charm. The decor calls to mind the arts and craft movement, so expect rich colors and simple, bold designs in the fabrics. Charming cabins, cottages, and luxury suites are available—preserving details like fireplaces while adding modern amenities like flat-screen TVs and updated bathrooms. Mornings start with a gourmet breakfast in the dining room. Top ski attractions are minutes away, as are most summer activities in the Hunter Mountain area. Pets are welcome with advance notification.

Pros

  • Handsome main building
  • Perfect for couples
  • Manicured grounds

Cons

  • Must drive to most activities
  • Frequent group events
57 Hill St., Tannersville, NY, 12485, USA
518-589–6740
Hotel Details
Credit cards accepted
9 rooms, 8 cabin-style rooms, 2 cottages
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Fairlawn Inn

$ | 7872 Main St., Hunter, NY, 12442, USA

Just a short stroll from the slopes at Hunter Mountain, you can see the mountains from your room at this Queen Anne Victorian, complete with gorgeous corner turret, wraparound porch, and lovely gardens. With original details like parquet floors, wood paneling, and stained-glass windows, the pristine rooms have wrought-iron, four-poster, carved-wood, or brass queen beds; some have fireplaces, clawfoot tubs, and antique dressing tables. Fellow guests mingle and chat about their days on the slopes in the house's many common areas.

Pros

  • Great front porch
  • Awesome antiques
  • Reasonable rates

Cons

  • Decor can be a little busy
  • Some street noise
7872 Main St., Hunter, NY, 12442, USA
518-263–5025
Hotel Details
Credit cards accepted
9 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Washington Irving Inn

$$ | 6629 Rte. 23A, Hunter, NY, 12442, USA

Formerly a summer home for New York's high society, this 1890 inn retains many original architectural details—including lustrous dark-wood paneling, stained-glass windows, built-in bookcases, and carved fireplace mantels. Guest rooms contain some lovely antiques, patterned wallpaper, and beautifully refinished woodwork.Three have private balconies. If you're looking for more privacy, there are also two cottages shaded by maple trees. Breakfast and afternoon tea are included.

Pros

  • Delightful afternoon tea
  • Central location
  • Charming decor

Cons

  • Extra charge for children
  • Minimum stay for holidays
6629 Rte. 23A, Hunter, NY, 12442, USA
518-589–5560
Hotel Details
Credit cards accepted
Closed late Apr.–early May
13 rooms, 2 cottages
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video