2 Best Hotels in Ithaca, The Finger Lakes

Background Illustration for Hotels

Ithaca is a university town, so book far in advance during busy events like graduation and orientation at Cornell University and Ithaca College. Rooms also book up during big events at the Watkins Glen speedway.

William Henry Miller Inn

$$$ | 303 N Aurora St., Ithaca, NY, 14850, USA Fodor's Choice

Rooms at this inn, an 1880 Queen Anne downtown, are imaginatively decorated to highlight alcoves, built-in shelves, curved walls, and steeple views of the city center. Furnishings are traditional and pretty: European armoires, cherrywood sleigh beds and four-poster beds, and wood shutters. Breakfast is excellent, with treats like a homemade English muffin topped with scrambled eggs, smoked salmon, and asparagus, plus fresh juice and assorted muffins. A dessert buffet is offered in the evening.

Pros

  • Every detail attended to—down to the hand-ironed sheets
  • Modern bathrooms
  • Walking distance to Cornell and Ithaca Commons

Cons

  • Small TVs
303 N Aurora St., Ithaca, NY, 14850, USA
607-256--4553
Hotel Details
Credit cards accepted
9 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Inn on Columbia

$$$ | 228 Columbia St., Ithaca, NY, 14850, USA

An 1830s Greek Revival mansion was completely renovated to create the main building of this unconventional B&B. Accommodations are rooms, suites, and cottages, some a block away from the main inn. The design is contemporary, with custom-designed furniture by architect and co-owner Kenn Young. Suites and cottages have gas fireplaces. Kenn's wife Madeline, a chef, prepares breakfast. The owners are fairly hands-off.

Pros

  • Near Ithaca Commons
  • More private than most B and Bs

Cons

  • Books up early for college events
  • Some accommodations are at a different location
228 Columbia St., Ithaca, NY, 14850, USA
607-272--0204
Hotel Details
10 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?