3 Best Hotels in Hatteras Island, The North Carolina Coast

Background Illustration for Hotels

We've compiled the best of the best in Hatteras Island - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

The Inn on Pamlico Sound

$$ | 49684 Rte. 12, Buxton, NC, 27920, USA Fodor's Choice

You'll feel like an honored houseguest in this casually elegant, full-service boutique hotel, with sweeping waterfront views, intuitive rather than intrusive service, and an indoor-outdoor fine-dining restaurant, Café Pamlico. Lounge by the pool, walk out to the dock, or relax on an array of decks and porches, all designed to maximize the sunset experience over the sound. Schedule an in-room spa treatment, borrow a movie to watch in the 14-seat theater, or kick up your heels by stand-up paddleboarding, kayaking, fishing, or bicycling through the Buxton Woods Preserve that's just across the street. There's a full-service bar and regularly scheduled live music.

Pros

  • Rooms come in a variety of configurations and price ranges
  • Complimentary bikes and fishing and beach gear
  • Full gourmet breakfast

Cons

  • Pool is small enough to only be comfortable for one party at a time
  • Some decor showing hints of age
  • No elevators
49684 Rte. 12, Buxton, NC, 27920, USA
866-995–7030
Hotel Details
12 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Breakwater Inn

$ | 57896 Rte. 12, Hatteras Village, NC, 27943, USA
At this comfortable inn with spacious rooms with kitchenettes—suitable for a long weekend or short vacation—you can kick back on your wide, private balcony and watch the action as boats come and go from the Oden's Dock marina just below. There's a small pool right by the road, and the on-site Breakwater Restaurant is one of the island's best.

Pros

  • Oversized mini-refrigerators
  • Sound views from your porch
  • Walking distance to several restaurants

Cons

  • Buildings across the marina block the sunset during some months
  • Only a dumbwaiter elevator
  • No views from Fisherman's Quarters annex
57896 Rte. 12, Hatteras Village, NC, 27943, USA
252-986–2565
Hotel Details
35 rooms
No Meals

Quick Facts

  • $

Something incorrect in this review?

Watermen's Retreat

$$$$ | 25706 Rte. 12, Rodanthe, NC, 27982, USA

This waterfront resort takes advantage of the perfect kiteboarding conditions just outside its door—and the surf break just across the road—offering an everything-you-need complex that includes modern, luxury suites with views of the action, an upscale restaurant and rum bar, and the REAL Watersports store, all on-site. In addition to the main building's suites, there are cabanas and a stand-alone cottage.

Pros

  • Fresh, well-appointed condos
  • On-site kiteboarding lessons
  • Quality waterfront café

Cons

  • Minimum stays vary as high as four nights
  • Not all suites have water views
  • Small parking lot
25706 Rte. 12, Rodanthe, NC, 27982, USA
252-987–6060
Hotel Details
25 condos
No Meals

Quick Facts

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Not finding what you're looking for?

We've got a few suggestions for nearby spots.
$$ Ocracoke Island Fodor's Choice

Captain's Landing Waterfront Inn18 miles away

324 Irvin Garrish Hwy., Ocracoke Island, North Carolina, 27960, USA
We recommend 2 Hotels in Ocracoke Island
$ Ocracoke Island

Ocracoke Harbor Inn18.2 miles away

144 Silver Lake Rd., Ocracoke Island, North Carolina, 27960, USA
We recommend 2 Hotels in Ocracoke Island
$$$$ Roanoke Island

White Doe Inn47.6 miles away

319 Sir Walter Raleigh St., Manteo, North Carolina, 27954, USA
We recommend 2 Hotels in Roanoke Island
$$$ Roanoke Island

Tranquil House Inn47.8 miles away

405 Queen Elizabeth Ave., Manteo, North Carolina, 27954, USA
We recommend 2 Hotels in Roanoke Island
$$ Nags Head Fodor's Choice

First Colony Inn48.6 miles away

6715 S. Croatan Hwy., Nags Head, North Carolina, 27959, USA
We recommend 2 Hotels in Nags Head