2 Best Hotels in Montgomery and Jay, Northern Vermont

Background Illustration for Hotels

We've compiled the best of the best in Montgomery and Jay - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

The INN

$$ | 241 Main St., Montgomery, VT, 05471, USA Fodor's Choice

This smart chalet-style lodge comes with tons of character. The rooms in back have Trout River views, and the 1890 main building is cozier than ever, with a sofa-heavy common area warmed by a wood-burning fireplace and a lively bar and restaurant serving American comfort food.

Pros

  • Trout River views from back rooms
  • Within walking distance of shops and supplies
  • Smart, individually designed rooms

Cons

  • Noise from bar can seep into nearby rooms
  • Two-night minimum stay generally required
  • Outside food and alcohol not allowed
241 Main St., Montgomery, VT, 05471, USA
802-326–4391
Hotel Details
Closed mid-Apr.--mid-May, and early--late Nov.
11 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?

Phineas Swann Bed & Breakfast Inn

$$ | 195 Main St., Montgomery, VT, 05471, USA

The top-hatted bulldog on the sign of this 1880 farmhouse isn't just a mascot: it reflects the hotel's welcoming attitude to pet owners. Inside, a playful attitude permeates the colorful common areas, rooms, and suites, evinced by a seemingly endless supply of knickknacks.

Pros

  • Walking distance from shops and supplies
  • Lots of dogs
  • Each room has different design

Cons

  • Decor is a tad old-fashioned
  • Dog theme (and actual dogs) not for everyone
  • No outside alcohol allowed
195 Main St., Montgomery, VT, 05471, USA
802-326–4306
Hotel Details
9 rooms
Free Breakfast

Quick Facts

  • $$

Something incorrect in this review?