6 Best Restaurants in Cody, Sheridan, and Northern Wyoming, Wyoming

Background Illustration for Restaurants

Although not every community here has the eclectic mix of dining options common in more urban areas, there are plenty of small restaurants and local cafés with inimitable appeal. The larger communities often have several ethnic eateries from which to choose, serving everything from traditional Mexican and Native American specialties to Old World Italian and modern Korean dishes. The real strength of the region’s dining, however, lies with the basics. In almost any small-town watering hole you can order up some of the freshest and best-tasting beef and buffalo in the world. Whether it’s prime rib and mashed potatoes with sunflower bread or charred rib eye with corn on the cob, the area’s best meals are simple yet filled with a flavor found only in the West.

The Station by Cody Coffee

$ Fodor's Choice
The downtown branch of this excellent small-batch coffee roaster with a flagship café by the airport occupies a colorfully restored and decorated former gas station with a landscaped patio. In addition to well-crafted espresso drinks, both locations of Cody Coffee offer an extensive menu of sweet and savory crepes and triple-decker sandwiches.

8th Street at the Ivy

$$$
A short drive west of downtown, this high-ceilinged regional American restaurant with deep booth seats and big windows looking out toward the mountains draws guests but also quite a few locals for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Regionally sourced meat and seafood are the stars here, including fall-off-the-bone short ribs and flavorful grilled Idaho trout.

Eggingtons

$$
It's not uncommon to see a line out the door here on weekend mornings. With a wide selection of breakfast and lunch options, there's something for everyone. Eggingtons' warm and casual atmosphere paired delicious offerings like four different kinds of Benedicts keep locals and tourists coming back.
229 E. 2nd St., Casper, WY, 82601, USA
307-265--8700
Known For
  • 6 am opening time for the early birds
  • Build-your-own breakfast tacos and omelets
  • Nine staple burgers to choose from
Restaurant Details
No dinner

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

P.O. News & Flagstaff Cafe

$$$
A tobacco store in the front and a casual restaurant in the back, the historic Flagstaff Cafe is one of the longest-running, continually operating businesses in Wyoming. This classic family-style menu offers hearty breakfast and lunch to weary travelers and locals alike. The tobacco shop first opened in 1910; the café was added later.
1 N. Main St., Sheridan, WY, 82801, USA
307-673--5333
Known For
  • Locally sourced Legerski sausage
  • All hamburgers ground fresh every day by the nearby Sacketts Market
  • Convenient location in the heart of downtown Sheridan
Restaurant Details
Closed Sun. and Mon. No dinner

Something incorrect in this review?

Sackett's Market

$$
With a back-to-basics approach to food, Sackett's sells freshly butchered meats and fresh-picked vegetables free from all chemicals, additives, and preservatives. But the market has become equally popular for its delicious sandwiches, salads, and a fresh soup of the day, all made for take-out. Owner Paul Sackett Haworth's great grandfather came out west to help with the Buffalo Bill Wild West Show in the 1800s before moving the family to Big Horn, Wyoming and opening the Big Horn Mercantile. Paul takes the same principles of providing great quality food to his community at this fully stocked market.
184 E. Burkitt St., Sheridan, WY, 82801, USA
307-672--3663
Known For
  • Smoked meats made in-house
  • Deli counter modeled after the original in Big Horn Mercantile
  • All products sourced from the mountain states
Restaurant Details
Closed Sun.

Something incorrect in this review?

Uptown Shabby Eatery & Catering

$$
With a farmhouse feel and an eclectic menu, this local favorite serves up iconic classics like skillet mac and cheese, flatbreads, and burgers, each with their own twists. You won't be leaving hungry here with meals like French PBC&B sandwich (peanut butter, chocolate, and banana served between French toast) or jalapeño popper mac and cheese. Inspiration is drawn from the owner's grandfather, a French-Italian chef.
1 E. Alger St., Sheridan, WY, USA
307-763--4133
Known For
  • The famous blueberry cheesecake burger
  • Weekend breakfast kabacos (kebab tacos)
  • Authentic French crepes

Something incorrect in this review?