14 Best Hotels in The Catskills, New York

Name: The Graham and Co.
Address: 80 Rte. 214, Phoenicia, New York, 12464, US
Telephone: 845-688–7871
Price range: $$

We've compiled the best of the best in The Catskills - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

The Graham and Co.

$$ | 80 Rte. 214, Phoenicia, NY, 12464, USA Fodor's Choice

Recalling the summer camp atmosphere of the '50s and '60s and the heyday of the Catskills, the Graham and Co. has weekend bonfires, hammocks hanging under the trees, a volleyball net (often transformed into an outdoor movie screen), and simple but cool guest rooms decorated with vintage maps and fans, rough hewn wood, and industrial light fixtures. Float in an inner tube in the oval pool or grab one of the free bikes and head to the bustling main drag of the charming town of Phoenicia. There are no TVs in the rooms, just Tivoli radios and free Hi-Fi. Other listed amenities include "togetherness" and "camraderie." Explain that to the kids!

Hotel Mountain Brook

$$ | 57 Hill St., Tannersville, NY, 12485, USA Fodor's Choice

Originally constructed in the 1940s, this Adirondacks-style lodge has been thoroughly updated without losing any of its period charm. The decor calls to mind the arts and craft movement, so expect rich colors and simple, bold designs in the fabrics. Charming cabins, cottages, and luxury suites are available—preserving details like fireplaces while adding modern amenities like flat-screen TVs and updated bathrooms. Mornings start with a gourmet breakfast in the dining room. Top ski attractions are minutes away, as are most summer activities in the Hunter Mountain area. Pets are welcome with advance notification.

Stickett Inn

$$ | 3380 Rte. 97, Barryville, NY, 12719, USA Fodor's Choice

In a handsome building with rough-hewn columns holding up the front porch, this rustic-hip retreat in the riverside hamlet of Barryville has just four suites: one has a private balcony with a spiral staircase leading down to a hot tub, while another has a glassed-in steam shower and a cold-plunge trough tub. In another room, a rain shower is positioned above a round metal tub big enough for two. Best of all is the separate two-bedroom cabin, which calls to mind the region's kitschy motels with a Formica dinette set, cabinets covered with paint-by-numbers art, and an Elvis Presley lamp.

Recommended Fodor's Video

The Arnold House

$$ | 839 Shandelee Rd., Livingston Manor, NY, 12758, USA

With a history that dates back more than a century, The Arnold House helped make this part of the Catskills a must-go destination for hip city dwellers looking for a weekend in the country. The 10 guest rooms blend old and new seamlessly, with antique writing desks and quilts that preserve the country aesthetic alongside industrial touches like metal chairs and swing-out reading lamps. There's also a two-bedroom lake house that makes this property perfect for family reunions and weekend escapes. A spiral staircase takes you down to a rustic tavern, where locally caught trout (lightly breaded and pan-fried) is among the favorites. In warm weather you can sit on the deck and count the stars. On summer weekends there's often live music in the barn out back. For relaxation, you can book a treatment at the spa or just wander down to the pretty little pond.

Enchanted Manor of Woodstock

$$ | 23 Rowe Rd., Woodstock, NY, 12401, USA

Inside this white-columned brick house, a fireplace warms a large living room where plush upholstery invites you to unwind, as do the seemingly endless decks leading to a heated pool, hot tub, and pond—all framed by eight acres of forest. Rooms are decorated with antiques and plenty of country charm. The suite has its own living room and fireplace, and some rooms have hot tubs. Spa treatments include a variety of massage and facial treatments. Health and wellness runs deep here: there are no chemicals in the pool and smoking is not allowed anywhere on the property.

Four Corners Country Inn

$$ | 1564 Wittenberg Rd., Mount Tremper, NY, 12457, USA

As you pull into the gravel driveway and climb the steps of this plain but pretty 1850s Victorian, you will feel like you're visiting a favorite relative. Named for nearby hamlets like Chichester and Woodstock, the reasonably priced rooms are simply decorated and include some well-chosen antiques. Some, like the Wittenberg, are unusually large and can accommodate the whole family. The dining room is a showplace, with a long, elegant bar that was made in the 1920s. A lavish breakfast is included.

Hunter Inn

$$ | 7433 Main St., Hunter, NY, 12442, USA

This chalet-style hotel has a great location less than a mile from Hunter Mountain and some rooms have patios or balconies with views of the surrounding forest and the ski slopes. If you're here with family, you'll want to upgrade to a suite with cathedral ceilings, a loft sleeping area, and a living area where everyone can relax. There's an outdoor hot tub, an arcade for the kids, and coffee is always brewing in the lobby. A buffet breakfast is included in the rates.

Ask for an even-numbered room, as they face the gorgeous scenery.

Kaatskill Mountain Club

$$ | 7740 Main St., Hunter, NY, 12442, USA

You can't get much closer to the slopes than at handsome Kaatskill Mountain Club, which overlooks two of Hunter Mountain's ski lifts. All the accommodations here are suites, with their own sitting areas. The amenities pile up fast once you upgrade, with even the smaller rooms offering pullout sofas for extra guests, full kitchens, and gas fireplaces. The larger rooms have extras like whirlpool tubs and views onto the downhill runs. There's also an outdoor heated pool, two hot tubs, a game room, and a fitness room. Van Winkles, the on-site restaurant, serves dinner daily and breakfast and lunch on the weekends. If you overdo things while skiing or snowboarding, head to the spa for a rejuvenating massage.

Nest Inn

$$ | 15 Main St., Narrowsburg, NY, 12764, USA

Owner Anna Bern runs the chic antique and clothing store around the corner, and many of her best pieces find their way into the two guest rooms of this 1850s farmhouse. The former art director at W and design director at Vogue effortlessly mixes well-chosen antiques, midcentury treasures, and rugs found on her world travels. One of the rooms has an elegantly draped clawfoot tub in the bedroom, a very romantic touch. The walled garden with a fire pit is a great place for some rest and relaxation.

North Branch Inn

$$ | 869 N. Branch Rd., NY, 12766, USA

One of the newest properties in the Catskills, the North Branch Inn—a labor of love for the husband-and-wife team of Sims Foster and Kirsten Harlow Foster—is tucked away in a tiny town of the same name, and has lots of fun finds, like a screening room with a row of seats from Radio City Music Hall and an elegantly curved bar from the 1939 World's Fair. The best just might be the two-lane bowling alley, uncovered when this 1868 clapboard structure was renovated in 2015. In addition to a wood-paneled restaurant serving foods sourced from around New York State, there are five cozy guest rooms in the main building, where you'll find original woodwork and wide-plank floors. Across the street is a second building with four spacious suites where you can read in your own sitting area or soak in a claw-foot tub.

Thompson House

$$ | 19 Rte. 296, Windham, NY, 12496, USA

Built around a farmhouse dating from the 1880s, Thompson House has become an expansive family resort with plenty of activities to keep families happily occupied and comfortable. There's a large heated pool, tennis court, miniature golf, bocce, shuffleboard, basketball, a playground—and that's just for starters. Grown-ups can take advantages of all this, of course, as well as the putting green and fitness center. Guest rooms are spread among six buildings; the standard rooms are not as charming as the suites, so it's worth paying a little extra if you care about four-poster beds and other nice details. Rates include breakfast and dinner.

Washington Irving Inn

$$ | 6629 Rte. 23A, Hunter, NY, 12442, USA

Formerly a summer home for New York's high society, this 1890 inn retains many original architectural details—including lustrous dark-wood paneling, stained-glass windows, built-in bookcases, and carved fireplace mantels. Guest rooms contain some lovely antiques, patterned wallpaper, and beautifully refinished woodwork.Three have private balconies. If you're looking for more privacy, there are also two cottages shaded by maple trees. Breakfast and afternoon tea are included.

Winwood Mountain Inn

$$ | Windham, NY, 12496, USA

Sitting on 12 acres in the mountains, this family-oriented property offers a variety of accommodations, from standard rooms to suites with one or two bedrooms to spacious condos with room enough for six people. The condos, which account for the bulk of the units, are spacious and have either private patios or balconies. All accommodations are outfitted in a comfortable American decor with cherrywood furniture. There's a restaurant on-site as well as a movie theater and fitness room. There's a free shuttle to the ski area, and all the attractions in town are a short walk away.

Woodstock Inn on the Millstream

$$ | 48 Tannery Brook Rd., Woodstock, NY, 12498, USA

Tall pines stand sentinel at this lovely lodging, creating a private haven a short walk from the center of Woodstock. After splashing in the swimming hole you can stroll along the stream or relax on the landscaped lawn. The most basic rooms are in a motel-style complex dating from the 1940s. Hanging flower planters adorn front porches, handsome antiques add country charm, and quilts cover beds. Other rooms have fireplaces, galley kitchens, and hardwood floors. For more privacy, there are two stand-alone cottages with lots of windows and private outdoor seating areas. The continental breakfast spread is bountiful, and has plenty of options for vegetarians and vegans.

The Catskills

The Catskills

Recommended Fodor's Video

Follow Us

Thank you for your interest!