4 Best Restaurants in Hatteras Island, The North Carolina Coast

Background Illustration for Restaurants

We've compiled the best of the best in Hatteras Island - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Café Pamlico

$$$$ Fodor's Choice

Overlooking Pamlico Sound, this upscale bistro focuses squarely on locally sourced seafood, vegetables from the accompanying inn's garden, and friendly service by local staff. Among the favorites are shrimp and grits, grilled catch of the day, tuna ceviche, and crab cakes. There's a dedicated vegan menu, live music at least two nights a week, and a popular Sunday brunch.

49684 Rte. 12, Buxton, NC, 27920, USA
252-995–4500
Known For
  • Gorgeous sunsets
  • Fine-dining atmosphere rare on Outer Banks
  • Crab cakes that don't skimp on the crab
Restaurant Details
No dinner Sun.

Something incorrect in this review?

Dancing Turtle Coffee Shop

$
The long list of mocha varieties at this early-morning hot spot tempt you to deviate from your usual latte, and the fluffy muffins and scones only add to the decadence. All-fruit smoothies offer a healthy balance.
57196 Saxon Cut Dr., Hatteras Village, NC, 27943, USA
252-986–4004
Known For
  • Long specialty smoothie menu
  • Coffee drinks with elaborate flavor options
  • Grab-and-go pastries
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon.

Something incorrect in this review?

Oceana's Bistro

$$$

Look for a roadside aquamarine horse painted with starfish and coral to find this long-established, welcoming spot to get local seafood, pasta, or a wrap. Daily specials range from prime rib to tacos and grillers, a cross between a pizza and a quesadilla that's topped with tuna, crab, chicken, or veggies. The bistro has a full bar and a good selection of local beers to wash it all down with, and they stay open year-round for lunch and dinner (seasonally for breakfast).

Recommended Fodor's Video

Orange Blossom Bakery & Cafe

$

There's a line out the door during summer for this bakery's "Apple Uglies," fried amalgams of doughnut dough and apples. There's also a full menu of breakfast burritos and egg sandwiches to enjoy on the patio out front. 

47206 Rte. 12, Buxton, NC, 27920, USA
Known For
  • Pastries doused in chocolate
  • Homemade biscuit sandwiches
  • Breakfast burritos
Restaurant Details
Closed weekdays Jan.–mid-Mar.

Something incorrect in this review?