8 Best Restaurants in Sicily, Italy

Background Illustration for Restaurants

We've compiled the best of the best in Sicily - browse our top choices for the top things to see or do during your stay.

Agriturismo Antica Tindari

$$ Fodor's Choice

This restaurant is located within a local vineyard between Patti and Tindari near the stunning Gulf of Patti, the lakes of Marinello, and Santuario di Tindari. With its extensive terrace views over the vines and olive groves, it's a beautiful place to stop and savor good food, great wine, and local hospitality.

I Banchi

$$$ Fodor's Choice

Gabriella Cicero's one-stop restaurant and gourmet food shop delvers a plethora of Sicilian slow-foodie delights, from scrumptious street-food scaccia and panelle staples to an exquisite, superb-value tasting menu foregrounding Sicilian produce and culinary history. Under the stylishly adorned stone vaults of the centuries-old Palazzo Diquattro, diners dive into classic seafood spaghetto taratatatà (with tuna roe, almonds, and lemon), then the unmissable chocolate-glazed pork collar with artichoke and potato purée. The wonderful staff expertly match wines from the extensively-stocked cantina.  

Maidda Panificio

$ Fodor's Choice

For the tastiest snacks head to this neighborhood bakery for a selection of traditional savory bites and focaccia. Pack a picnic, and embrace your carb cravings with their fresh bread and dolci delights such as ricotta-filled nfigghiulate, nutty 'n' fruity tortini, and raisin- or chocolate-dotted paninetti buns.

Via Ducezio 85, Noto, 96017, Italy
0931-1622930
Known For
  • Scacce (a folded, filled flatbread)
  • Sicilian pizzas like lumera (a folded square with sauce and cheese) and Sficioni (extra thick covered with anchovy tomato sauce)
  • Rotteline pastry wheels filled with Ragusano DOP cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, and oregano
Restaurant Details
Closed Sun.

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Trattoria Sant’Anna

$ Fodor's Choice

This wonderful restaurant is housed in a part of the Palazzo Bongiorno, making it a beautiful spot to sit and savor the tastes and sights of Gangi and the Madonie. You will spoiled for choice from a menu of antipasti of local salumi and cheeses, hearty primi of mountain soups and pastas, slow-cooked, meaty main seconds, and roasted vegetable sides. 

Via Sant’Anna 2, 90024, Italy
0921-602422
Known For
  • Wonderful leafy courtyard for dining
  • Roast and grilled lamb, kid goat, beef, pork
  • Simple seasonal and local fare
Restaurant Details
Closed Wed.

Something incorrect in this review?

Il Castello Ristorante

$$

This casual restaurant and B&B is located in an impressive converted Norman castle. Dine in rustic yet elegant surroundings on hearty pasta dishes, meaty mains like slow-cooked pork shank, or wood-fired pizzas, all featuring seasonal Madonie mountain produce. 

Via Generale di Maria 27, Petralia Sottana, 90027, Italy
0921-641250
Known For
  • Beautiful castle location
  • Charming option to spend the night
  • Big cornicione-crust pizza with inventive toppings
Restaurant Details
Closed Tues.--Thurs. No lunch Fri., Sat., and Mon.

Something incorrect in this review?

Ricotta & Co

$

For simple, homemade cucina povera (simple "peasant" food) head to Concetta and Eliseo's popular place with a rustic dining room and buzzy terrace on Modica's melodious main drag, offering continuous service from 9 to 5. Among their hearty traditional plates, start with their signature hot ricotta, followed by lolli pasta with cottoia broad beans and slow-cooked pork in tomato sauce.   

Corso Umberto I, 261, Modica, 97015, Italy
0932-751132
Known For
  • Grilled meats and salads
  • Open all day for breakfast, brunch, and lazy lunch
  • Pasta and bakes using low-GI Rossello wheat
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon. No dinner

Something incorrect in this review?

Ristoro dello Scoiattolo

$$

This rustic mountain lodge is situated right near the popular winter skiing resort area of Piano Battaglia. Open throughout the year, it offers a cozy country panorama, good hearty local fare, and friendly service at very reasonable prices.

U Friscu

$

This cool, relaxed café-bar-restaurant is the hub of Scauri life, and has very loyal local following since it stays open all year long. The menu—written on a chalkboard—is strictly seasonal, featuring a nice mixture of traditional Sicilian dishes and more creative dishes, all focusing on island and mainland Sicilian produce and served on blue-rimmed white enamel plates.

Via S. Gaetano SNC, Pantelleria, Italy
0923-1570070
Known For
  • Simple interior and charming outdoor terrace
  • Platters of mixed cold cuts and cheeses or smoked fish to accompany evening aperitivi
  • Natural cloudy island wine from island producer Abbazia San Giorgio
Restaurant Details
Closed Tues. Oct.–Mar.

Something incorrect in this review?