8 Best Restaurants in Sicily, Italy

Feisty Concetta serves a set menu for lunch and dinner from her long terrace, located near the Chiesa San Bartolo. You can expect a large selection of antipasti (such as wild fennel, sautéed shrimp, and roasted eggplant), a pasta course, and some variety of roasted fish. It's true island home-cooking, done in abundance and served with incredible hospitality. 

Gabriella Cicero's one-stop restaurant and gourmet food shop delvers a plethora of Sicilian slow-foodie delights, from scrumptious street-food scaccia and panelle staples to an exquisite, superb-value tasting menu foregrounding Sicilian produce and culinary history. Under the stylishly adorned stone vaults of the centuries-old Palazzo Diquattro, diners dive into classic seafood spaghetto taratatatà (with tuna roe, almonds, and lemon), then the unmissable chocolate-glazed pork collar with artichoke and potato purée. The wonderful staff expertly match wines from the extensively-stocked cantina.  

Though this Michelin-starred restaurant is part of a hotel, it's worth a visit all on its own. Chef Giuseppe Raciti highlights the traditions and flavors of the area with a repertoire of elegant riffs that delight and surprise without overwhelming you with gimmicks. Located in a restored wine palmento (the traditional winemaking structure of Etna), the stone dining room looks over the surrounding citrus orchards whose scent wafts through the open windows. The owners for nigh on a hundred years, the Maugeri family, are winemakers, and naturally, you'll find their bottles on the wine list. But they are also wine lovers, and the roughly 70-page tome reflects that.  

A native of Naples, Ciro Aragione has called Stromboli home since the 1990s. From his home, he cooks lunch for visitors to the island, usually a set menu of pasta and fish he's bought straight off the boats that morning. In addition to the home restaurant—really a long table on his terrace flanked by lemon and mandarin trees—he can arrange catered picnics for your boat excursions or beach days, and will deliver to you.

In his humble kitchen, Silvio, a rosy-cheeked fisherman, cooks for his guests as they sit around the table. You might have a simple pasta with tomato sauce, eggplant from his garden, olives cured from his trees, simmered wild greens gathered from the hillsides, and a fish dish (roasted, fried, or sautéed). The menu really depends on what's in season, and more importantly, what Silvio caught that morning from his little wooden fishing boat. You'll eat well, but the food is almost beside the point.   

This traditional fine-dining eatery occupies a cozy-but-elegant space on an unheralded piazza in the historic city center. The seasonally changing menu offers fixed-price osteria fare based on seasonal ingredients, which you can order à la carte or on tasting menus (land, sea, or vegetarian). Local seafood is a big draw, and the house-made pastas won't disappoint, especially when paired with a selection from the extensive wine list. Reserve ahead for al fresco dining at one of the tables in the piazza.

Chef Davide and brother Luca (front of house) deliver gorgeous, imaginative dishes in an elegant, coved-ceiling salone with stylish mid-century chairs and Anglepoise lighting. Their compact, seasonal menu showcases wonderful Sicilian produce such as octopus, tuna, black pork, pumpkin, and porcini mushrooms.

This local institution, which has relocated to the town's new tourist port area, serves gourmet Italian classics—mainly fresh seafood but also few meat options. It's a mile or so out of town (and pricey), so perhaps it's worth the trip if you crave having some fancy food while watching the yachts of the modern marina location.