4 Best Restaurants in Bermuda

Background Illustration for Restaurants

What's incredible about the Bermuda restaurant scene isn't so much the number or quality of restaurants, but the sheer variety of cuisines represented on the menus, especially considering that Bermuda is such a tiny island. It hosts a medley of global cuisines—British, French, Italian, Portuguese, American, Caribbean, Indian, Chinese, and Thai—palatable reminders of Bermuda's history as a colony.

Many superior independent and resort restaurants attract a constant and steady stream of internationally acclaimed chefs, assuring that the latest techniques and trends are menu regulars. At the same time, virtually all restaurant menus list traditional Bermudian dishes and drinks, so you have the opportunity to taste local specialties at almost any meal.

As you might expect, methods are not all that's imported. Roughly 80% of Bermuda's food is flown or shipped in, most of it from the United States. This explains why restaurant prices are often higher here than on the mainland.

Nevertheless, there are a number of delicious local ingredients that you should look for. At the top of the list is extraordinary seafood, like lobster (best during September through March), crab, oysters, mussels, clams, red snapper, rockfish, tuna, and wahoo. Additionally, many chefs work with local growers to serve fresh seasonal fruits and vegetables, such as potatoes, carrots, leeks, tomatoes, corn, broccoli, and Bermuda onions (one of the island's earliest exports); and in the fruit department, strawberries, cherries, bananas, and loquats (small yellow fruit used for preserves). Imports notwithstanding, Bermudian cuisine really begins and ends with local ingredients and traditional preparations, and therein lies the island's culinary identity.

While in Bermuda, try to eat like a local and put a couple of traditional dishes to the test. Bermuda is a seafood lover’s paradise, with favorite dishes including mussel pie, shark hash, and codfish and bananas. As for soups, you can go for fish chowder, conch chowder, or traditional Portuguese black-eyed bean soup. Don’t forget to kick back and relax after your meal with a rum swizzle, a Black and Coke, or a Dark ’n' Stormy. Ginger beer—which is quite different from ginger ale—remains the island’s most popular soda for the kids.

Coconuts

$$$ Fodor's Choice

Perched between towering cliff rocks and a pristine private beach on the southern coast, Coconuts offers one of the most romantic dining experiences with breathtaking views of the ocean. Open seasonally during the summer, the menu changes frequently, but you can always expect a diverse selection—from drunken mussels to rockfish to braised oxtail—prepared with signature Bermudian flair, while also accommodating meat-free diets. Starting in May, the restaurant hosts a weekly beach BBQ. Due to its popularity, reservations for dinner and special events are recommended, as tables fill up quickly at this sought-after spot.

56 South Shore Rd., SN 02, Bermuda
441-238–0222
Known For
  • Romantic fixed-price dining on the beach
  • Varied menu including good local fish
  • Cheaper lunch menu offers weekly specials
Restaurant Details
Closed Nov.–Apr.
Reservations essential

Something incorrect in this review?

Harbourfront Restaurant

$$$

Whether you dine inside beside the enormous floor-to-ceiling windows or outside on the dock, every seat in this restaurant next to the Bermuda Underwater Exploration Institute has beautiful views of Hamilton Harbour. Expertly prepared fresh sushi shines alongside international specialties and locally caught fish on the remarkably eclectic menu, so don't hesitate to ask your attentive server to recommend a dish. Dinner favorites include Bermuda fish chowder, risotto porcini, and veal Milanese. The outdoor seating area overlooks Red Hole at the edge of Hamilton Harbour, providing a serene backdrop for a romantic dinner.

40 Crow La., Hamilton, HM19, Bermuda
441-295–4207
Known For
  • Sophisticated harborside setting
  • Monthly changing set menu
  • Inventive sushi menu
Restaurant Details
No lunch weekends

Something incorrect in this review?

JC's Café & Bistro

$$

JC’s Café is a go-to when you're craving good food without the fuss. The menu has plenty to tempt: think fluffy wraps, grilled paninis, crisp salads, and colorful bowls topped with island-style flair. Regulars swear by the refreshing fruit smoothies and the specialty coffee drinks, ideal for perking up after a morning in the sun. Inside, the vibe is bright and cheerful, with modern touches and cozy corners that invite you to settle in a little longer. There's another location in the Walker Arcade. 

29 Victoria St., Hamilton, HM 12, Bermuda
441-232–0503
Known For
  • Charming French-bistro atmosphere
  • Chicken and beef pies
  • Made-to-order cuisine
Restaurant Details
Closed Sun. No dinner Mon.–Thurs.

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Pastel

$$

True to its name, Pastel—the poolside bar and restaurant at Cambridge Beaches Resort & Spa—makes the most of its south shore setting, offering a tropical backdrop for a breezy island lunch or relaxed dinner. Travel the world from your table with shareable, tapas-style plates inspired by global flavors: tamari-gochujang-glazed Brussels sprouts, heirloom tomato and whipped ricotta salad, or steak Diane. Finish with dark Bermuda rum cake topped with caramel ice cream and forest berries. Many dishes can be adapted for dietary needs.

30 Kings Point Rd., Somerset, MA 02, Bermuda
441-234–0331
Known For
  • Eclectic international menu
  • Sophisticated poolside atmosphere
  • Ample gluten-free and vegetarian options
Restaurant Details
No dinner Mon.

Something incorrect in this review?