11 Best Restaurants in Bermuda

Background Illustration for Restaurants

What's incredible about the Bermuda restaurant scene isn't so much the number or quality of restaurants, but the sheer variety of cuisines represented on the menus, especially considering that Bermuda is such a tiny island. It hosts a medley of global cuisines—British, French, Italian, Portuguese, American, Caribbean, Indian, Chinese, and Thai—palatable reminders of Bermuda's history as a colony.

Many superior independent and resort restaurants attract a constant and steady stream of internationally acclaimed chefs, assuring that the latest techniques and trends are menu regulars. At the same time, virtually all restaurant menus list traditional Bermudian dishes and drinks, so you have the opportunity to taste local specialties at almost any meal.

As you might expect, methods are not all that's imported. Roughly 80% of Bermuda's food is flown or shipped in, most of it from the United States. This explains why restaurant prices are often higher here than on the mainland.

Nevertheless, there are a number of delicious local ingredients that you should look for. At the top of the list is extraordinary seafood, like lobster (best during September through March), crab, oysters, mussels, clams, red snapper, rockfish, tuna, and wahoo. Additionally, many chefs work with local growers to serve fresh seasonal fruits and vegetables, such as potatoes, carrots, leeks, tomatoes, corn, broccoli, and Bermuda onions (one of the island's earliest exports); and in the fruit department, strawberries, cherries, bananas, and loquats (small yellow fruit used for preserves). Imports notwithstanding, Bermudian cuisine really begins and ends with local ingredients and traditional preparations, and therein lies the island's culinary identity.

While in Bermuda, try to eat like a local and put a couple of traditional dishes to the test. Bermuda is a seafood lover’s paradise, with favorite dishes including mussel pie, shark hash, and codfish and bananas. As for soups, you can go for fish chowder, conch chowder, or traditional Portuguese black-eyed bean soup. Don’t forget to kick back and relax after your meal with a rum swizzle, a Black and Coke, or a Dark ’n' Stormy. Ginger beer—which is quite different from ginger ale—remains the island’s most popular soda for the kids.

Aurora

$$$ Fodor's Choice

Two-time Best of Bermuda Gold award-winning Aurora restaurant at Newstead Belmont Hills Resort showcases the dedication of local farmers and fishermen, with an ocean-to-table menu that lets the main ingredients shine. When you aren't marveling at the view, you'll find yourself colored impressed by the diverse menu featuring seafood delights like local yellowfin tuna ribbons, seafood paella, and catch of the day. Aurora also caters to vegetarians and vegans with a small but thoughtful selection. For a scenic and convenient journey, a complimentary water shuttle is available to transport you between the restaurant and various points around Hamilton Harbour. Note: Aurora maintains a dress code—no flip-flops or shorts (Bermuda shorts are fine), and men are asked to wear a collared shirt.

Barracuda Grill

$$$ Fodor's Choice

The tastefully decorated contemporary dining room—mahogany-framed chairs and banquettes, soft-gold lights over the tables—is reminiscent of sophisticated big-city restaurants, and the food (from both the sea and land) that comes to the table is created by a culinary team dedicated to excellence. Ease into your meal with a bowl of island-style fish chowder; for an entrée, try one of their classics, such as Bermuda rockfish or surf and turf—boneless beef ribs and fire-grilled king tiger shrimp. If you save room for dessert, opt for the artisanal cheese selection or perhaps the gingerbread toffee pudding. There's also a great cocktail bar for a social martini or late-night digestif. And if you're looking for a romantic dinner, reserve the "snug corner," which is a table for two, tucked away out of sight of other diners.

Gulfstream

$$ Fodor's Choice

Located just across from Horseshoe Bay, one of Bermuda’s most popular beaches, this restaurant serves up a variety of surf-and-turf dishes, including oysters, clams, and lobster, as well as sushi and plenty of options for vegetarians and selective eaters. Guests rave about the thin-crust pizzas and fresh fish, with sandwiches, tacos, and wraps offering satisfying alternatives after a day at the beach. Finger-licking starters round out the menu, while a sophisticated wine list and tempting desserts make for a perfect end to a meal under the island sun. Note that the restaurant is closed between lunch and dinner during the winter season.

Recommended Fodor's Video

Lost in the Triangle

$$ Fodor's Choice

Find yourself at Lost in the Triangle (LITT), a Bermudian-run seafood restaurant taking over from the Swizzle Inn's sister spot. Some may recall LITT from its award-winning tenure in the city of Hamilton. After COVID closures, owner and avid fisherman Delvin Bean was able to reopen and continue serving his signature dishes and fresh, locally caught fish. The atmosphere is welcoming, with TVs tuned to sports or cartoons for the little ones. Bike parking is ample. 

Port O Call

$$$ Fodor's Choice

A two-level restaurant and popular sushi bar (Pearl) with a modern look and elegant atmosphere, Port O Call is one of the few ground-entry dining spots on Front Street, with an outdoor dining area reminiscent of a chic European sidewalk café. The fresh local fish—such as wahoo, tuna, grouper, and snapper—is cooked perfectly, and the preparations are creative. Swing by around 5 pm to join a happy hour crowd of Bermuda's business elite and up-and-comers; Port O Call offers one of the island's most sophisticated dining and drinking experiences. For a romantic and delicious end to your evening, try a slice of their famous cheesecake.

87 Front St., Hamilton, HM 12, Bermuda
441-295–5373
Known For
  • Long wine list and creative drinks
  • Sceney happy hour
  • Delicious cheesecake
Restaurant Details
No lunch Sat. Closed Sun.

Something incorrect in this review?

Wahoo's Bistro & Patio

$$ Fodor's Choice

With a name like Wahoo's, it's no surprise that this restaurant's menu features a wide variety of fresh local seafood. Though often crowded, the patio offers an unbeatable view of the water; kids will love throwing scraps to schools of fish near the dock. Check the blackboard for the catch-of-the-day specials, and be sure to try the ever-popular wahoo tacos or wahoo nuggets. Whether it's served in a creamy chowder, on a bun, or over vegetables, Wahoo's does fish right.

36 Water St., St. George's, GE 05, Bermuda
441-297–1307
Known For
  • Catch-of-the-day specials
  • Fish chowder
  • Wahoo nuggets
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon. during winter

Something incorrect in this review?

Bone Fish Bar & Grill

$$

Service is relaxed, but the friendly vibe and big covered patio make Bone Fish a favorite with both locals and visitors. The breezy dining room is a cool break from the sun, and the menu covers everything from house-smoked brisket and homemade pastas to signature seafood tacos. Ask about the special lobster menu—think lobster tempura, risotto, and mac and cheese. Owner Livio Ferigo often pops by to chat with diners, and kids are covered with options like chicken tenders and cheese ravioli. Live entertainment, from guitarists to DJs and karaoke, keeps things lively all week.

Lobster Pot & Boat House Bar

$$

Bermudians swear by this spot, where a maritime-themed dining room is filled with brass nautical gear, lobster traps, and sun-bleached rope. The fresh local lobster, available September through March, is most requested, next to rockfish, snapper, wahoo, and mahi-mahi with fried bananas and almonds, all local favorites. Ask for your seafood to be cooked to your liking and be sure to try the Bermudian classic dish: fish chowder. The curried fish cake is a particular favorite, topped with tartar sauce and served on a bun. 

Mamma Mia

$

After gaining a solid following while running the café at Crystal Cave, Stefano Barioni has taken his award-winning fish sandwich and opened Mamma Mia at the Hamilton Parish Workmen's Club, or Crawl Club, as it is more commonly known. While the fresh, local fish sandwich is the standout, there is a large menu that includes breakfast specials and a variety of freshly cooked seafood choices. There are a few outdoor tables for seating.

6 Workmen's Ln., CR 02, Bermuda
441-261–6005
Known For
  • Award-winning fish sandwich
  • Local neighborhood favorite
  • Fresh seafood

Something incorrect in this review?

Seaside Grill

$

When it comes to iconic Bermudian food, the battered fish sandwich reigns supreme. While Seaside Grill may be a simple take-out counter overlooking North Shore, it has perfected this towering sandwich and earned rave reviews. Choose from locally caught wahoo or mahimahi, and watch as they pile crispy spiced fish onto your choice of homemade bread. For a true local twist, try it on raisin bread with sliced onion, tartar sauce, and coleslaw. Seaside Grill also offers fresh fish and seafood on salads, fish dinners with two sides, hamburgers, and chicken wings. With locations in Devonshire and Southampton, it's a must-try for a taste of Bermuda.

81 North Shore Rd., Flatts Village, FL 02, Bermuda
441-292–1241
Known For
  • Instagram-worthy fish sandwiches
  • Quick takeout options
  • Locally caught fish
Restaurant Details
Closed Sun.

Something incorrect in this review?

Sol i Mar

$$

The signature restaurant of Coco Reef Resort, Sol i Mar, Spanish for "sun and sea,"  lives up its name: the floor-to-ceiling windows provide excellent views of the sun-drenched south shore, while their contemporary seafood menu proudly features fresh locally-caught seafood. Table for two? Start by sharing tapas platters featuring shrimp, calamari, and chorizo, before moving on to seafood paella. To finish, traditional rum cake for dessert. The open atmosphere here has a slight Mediterranean influence, but the piece de resistance? It's the perfect setting for a romantic meal and a glass of wine from their extensive wine list, which features labels from around the world.