10 Best Restaurants in The Monterey Bay Area, California

Background Illustration for Restaurants

The Monterey Bay area is a culinary paradise. The surrounding waters are full of fish, wild game roams the foothills, and the inland valleys are some of the most fertile in the country—local chefs draw on this bounty for their fresh, truly Californian cuisine. Except at beachside stands and inexpensive eateries, where anything goes, casual but neat dress is the norm.

Fandango

$$$ Fodor's Choice

The menu here is mostly Mediterranean and southern French, with such dishes as osso buco and paella. The decor follows suit—stone walls and country furniture lend the restaurant the earthy feel of a European farmhouse.

Mentone

$$ Fodor's Choice

This spacious restaurant with soaring ceilings and floor-to-ceiling windows serves dishes featuring the authentic flavors of the French/Italian Riviera, from Nice to Genoa. The menu changes often, depending on ingredients acquired from local purveyors, but, in addition to house-made pizzas and traditional pastas, it might offer black-truffle cappellini in an Armagnac and truffle butter sauce, Dungeness crab gnocchi, or pork belly with squash and fennel in a scallop sauce. 

Casanova

$$$

This restaurant inspires European-style celebration and romance in an intimate French-country setting. Feast on authentic dishes from southern France and northern Italy—think beef tartare and escargot. Private dining is offered at Van Gogh's Table, a relic from France's Auberge Ravoux, the artist's final residence.

5th Ave., between San Carlos and Mission Sts., Carmel, CA, 93921, USA
831-625–0501
Known For
  • House-made pastas and gnocchi
  • Private dining at antique Van Gogh's table
  • Romantic candlelight dining room and outdoor patio
Restaurant Details
Reservations essential

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Gabriella Café

$$$

Local artwork features prominently at this petite, romantic café in a tile-roof cottage. Featuring organic produce from area farms, the seasonal Italian menu might include wild-mushroom risotto; bouillabaisse; marinated chicken with apricots, currants, and olives; and roasted beet salad with wild arugula, goat cheese, and pistachios.

910 Cedar St., Santa Cruz, CA, 95060, USA
831-457–1677
Known For
  • Nearly all produce comes from local organic farmers
  • Romantic interior with Moorish arches
  • Weekend brunch
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon. No dinner Sun.

Something incorrect in this review?

Grasing's Coastal Cuisine

$$$

Chef Kurt Grasing draws from fresh Carmel Coast and Central Valley ingredients to whip up contemporary adaptations of European-provincial and American dishes. Longtime menu favorites include fresh farm-raised abalone, a savory sausage and seafood paella, and grilled steaks and chops.

6th Ave. and Mission St., Carmel, CA, 93921, USA
831-624–6562
Known For
  • Artichoke and fontina ravioli
  • Grilled steaks
  • Bar, patio lounge, and rooftop deck
Restaurant Details
Reservations essential

Something incorrect in this review?

Red House Café

$$

When it's nice out, sun pours through the big windows of this cozy restaurant and across tables on the porch; when fog rolls in, the fireplace is lit. The American menu changes with the seasons, but grilled lamb chops atop mashed potatoes are often on offer for dinner, and a grilled calamari steak might be served for lunch, either in a salad or as part of a sandwich.

Roux

$$$$

Chef Fabrice Roux, who hails from France, worked at lauded Parisian restaurants for more than a decade before coming to Carmel Valley to wow diners with his contemporary takes on traditional French-Mediterranean cuisine. The eclectic menu, with mostly small and large plates meant for sharing, focuses on local ingredients procured that week—perhaps crispy duck leg confit, tuna tartare, or braised wild-boar bourguignon. Order sandwiches, beignets, and French-style egg dishes for brunch and lunch. Save room for house-made desserts like Meyer lemon cheesecake and crème brûlée.

6 Pilot Rd., Carmel Valley, CA, 93924, USA
831-659–5020
Known For
  • Expert food and wine pairings
  • European-style cottage with private room for dining and tastings
  • Extensive wine list with more than 400 labels
Restaurant Details
Closed Tues. No lunch Wed. and Thurs.

Something incorrect in this review?

Stationaery

$$

This cozy neighborhood restaurant serves one of Carmel’s most popular brunches every day, plus dinner several nights a week. The eclectic seasonal menu focuses on elegant comfort food with an international flair—options vary, but might include caviar with crème fraiche and kettle chips, shakshuka, chilaquiles, or poke bowls for brunch and soft-shell crab with fava bean puree for dinner.

San Carlos St., Carmel, CA, 93921, USA
831-250–7183
Known For
  • Specialty coffee, natural wines
  • Fresh, locally sourced ingredients
  • Takeout window
Restaurant Details
No dinner Sun.–Wed.

Something incorrect in this review?

Tarpy's Roadhouse

$$$

Fun, dressed-up American favorites—a little something for everyone—are served in this renovated early-1900s stone farmhouse several miles east of town. The kitchen cranks out everything from Cajun-spiced prawns to meat loaf with marsala-mushroom gravy to grilled ribs and steaks.

2999 Monterey–Salinas Hwy., Monterey, CA, 93940, USA
831-647–1444
Known For
  • American comfort food with a California twist
  • Rustic dining near an indoor fireplace or out in a garden courtyard
  • Generous portions

Something incorrect in this review?

Wild Fish

$$$

Inventive dishes—made with 100% organic and locally sourced ingredients—live music, and a friendly staff are among the reasons why this intimate, ocean-to-table eatery is packed on weekends. Everything is fresh as it gets, from fish-and-chips, Monterey Bay bouillabaisse, and whole roasted fish of the day to local greens with spicy vinaigrette.

545 Lighthouse Ave., Pacific Grove, CA, 93950, USA
831-373–8523
Known For
  • Cured house-smoked sablefish
  • Jazz quartet on Friday and Saturday nights
  • Smoked fish chowder

Something incorrect in this review?