16 Best Restaurants in The Monterey Bay Area, California

Background Illustration for Restaurants

The Monterey Bay area is a culinary paradise. The surrounding waters are full of fish, wild game roams the foothills, and the inland valleys are some of the most fertile in the country—local chefs draw on this bounty for their fresh, truly Californian cuisine. Except at beachside stands and inexpensive eateries, where anything goes, casual but neat dress is the norm.

Fandango

$$$ Fodor's Choice

The menu here is mostly Mediterranean and southern French, with such dishes as osso buco and paella. The decor follows suit—stone walls and country furniture lend the restaurant the earthy feel of a European farmhouse.

Passionfish

$$$ Fodor's Choice

South American artwork and artifacts decorate Passionfish, and Latin and Asian flavors infuse the dishes. The chef shops at local farmers' markets several times a week to find the best produce, fish, and meat available and then pairs it with creative sauces like a caper, raisin, and walnut relish.

701 Lighthouse Ave., Pacific Grove, CA, 93950, USA
831-655–3311
Known For
  • Sustainably sourced and organic ingredients
  • Reasonably priced wine list that supports small producers
  • Slow-cooked meats
Restaurant Details
No lunch

Something incorrect in this review?

The Pocket

$$$ Fodor's Choice

In surf lingo, "the pocket" is a perfect riding spot within a barrel-shape wave, and this Italian–Californian restaurant is likewise a perfect (casual and unfussy) gathering spot for those who seek first-rate food, wine, and cocktails. The chefs craft seasonal menus that focus on seafood, fresh pastas, curries, steaks, and braised meats.

Lincoln St., between 5th and 6th Ave., Carmel, CA, 93921, USA
831-626–8000
Known For
  • Sleek marble, wood, and slate dining room, spacious garden seating
  • Full bar, extensive list of more than 400 wines
  • Lively atmosphere, especially during the daily happy hour
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon. and Tues. No lunch

Something incorrect in this review?

Recommended Fodor's Video

Beach House

$$$

Patrons of this bluff-top perch sip classic cocktails, sample California fare, and watch the otters frolic on Lovers Point Beach below. The sunset discounts between 4 and 5:30 (reservations recommended) are a great value. For the best views of the beach and bay, sit on the heated outdoor patio.

620 Ocean View Blvd., Pacific Grove, CA, 93950, USA
831-375–2345
Known For
  • Sweeping bluff-top views
  • Heated patio
  • Seafood and organic pastas
Restaurant Details
No lunch

Something incorrect in this review?

Bittersweet Bistro

$$$

A large old tavern with cathedral ceilings houses this popular bistro, where the Mediterranean--California menu changes seasonally, but regular highlights include paella, seafood puttanesca, and pepper-crusted rib-eye steak with Cabernet demi-glace.

787 Rio Del Mar Blvd., Aptos, CA, 95003, USA
831-662–9799
Known For
  • Value-laden happy hour
  • Seafood specials
  • House-made desserts
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon. and Tues. No lunch, but open at 2 for dinner

Something incorrect in this review?

Café Rustica

$$$

European country cooking is the focus at this lively roadhouse, where specialties include roasted meats, seafood, pastas, and thin-crust pizzas from the wood-fired oven. It can get noisy inside; for a quieter meal, request a table outside.

10 Delfino Pl., Carmel Valley, CA, 93924, USA
831-659–4444
Known For
  • Tuscan-flavored dishes from Alsace
  • Open kitchen with wood-fired oven
  • Outdoor patio seating
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon. No lunch Tues. and Wed.
Reservations essential

Something incorrect in this review?

Casanova

$$$

This restaurant inspires European-style celebration and romance in an intimate French-country setting. Feast on authentic dishes from southern France and northern Italy—think beef tartare and escargot. Private dining is offered at Van Gogh's Table, a relic from France's Auberge Ravoux, the artist's final residence.

5th Ave., between San Carlos and Mission Sts., Carmel, CA, 93921, USA
831-625–0501
Known For
  • House-made pastas and gnocchi
  • Private dining at antique Van Gogh's table
  • Romantic candlelight dining room and outdoor patio
Restaurant Details
Reservations essential

Something incorrect in this review?

Estéban Restaurant

$$$

A festive dining room with a fireplace at the Casa Munras hotel is the setting for meals featuring modern and classic versions of empanadas, crispy Spanish octopus, flash-fried wild Gulf prawns, and five types of paella. Midweek specials abound—on Tuesday night, feast on a three-course prix-fixe paella dinner ($38 per person), bottles of wine are half off on Monday, and Wednesday wine flights are just $16 for three tastes.

700 Munras Ave., Monterey, CA, 93940, USA
831-375–0176
Known For
  • Daily tapas happy hour from 4:30 to 6
  • Patio with firepit
  • Special menus for kids and pups
Restaurant Details
No lunch

Something incorrect in this review?

Gabriella Café

$$$

Local artwork features prominently at this petite, romantic café in a tile-roof cottage. Featuring organic produce from area farms, the seasonal Italian menu might include wild-mushroom risotto; bouillabaisse; marinated chicken with apricots, currants, and olives; and roasted beet salad with wild arugula, goat cheese, and pistachios.

910 Cedar St., Santa Cruz, CA, 95060, USA
831-457–1677
Known For
  • Nearly all produce comes from local organic farmers
  • Romantic interior with Moorish arches
  • Weekend brunch
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon. No dinner Sun.

Something incorrect in this review?

Grasing's Coastal Cuisine

$$$

Chef Kurt Grasing draws from fresh Carmel Coast and Central Valley ingredients to whip up contemporary adaptations of European-provincial and American dishes. Longtime menu favorites include fresh farm-raised abalone, a savory sausage and seafood paella, and grilled steaks and chops.

6th Ave. and Mission St., Carmel, CA, 93921, USA
831-624–6562
Known For
  • Artichoke and fontina ravioli
  • Grilled steaks
  • Bar, patio lounge, and rooftop deck
Restaurant Details
Reservations essential

Something incorrect in this review?

L'Escargot

$$$

Chef-owner Kericos Loutas personally sees to each plate of food served at this romantic, unpretentious French restaurant. Order the pan-roasted duck breast or the pork medallions with wild mushrooms or white wine sauce; or, if you can't decide, choose the three-course prix-fixe dinner.

Mission and 4th Ave., Carmel, CA, 93921, USA
831-620–1942
Known For
  • Authentic French-country dishes
  • Prix-fixe dinner option
  • Locally sourced ingredients
Restaurant Details
Closed Mon. and Tues.
Reservations essential

Something incorrect in this review?

Oswald

$$$

Sophisticated yet unpretentious European-inspired California cooking is the order of the day at this intimate and stylish bistro, whose seasonal menu might include such items as seafood risotto or crispy duck breast in a pomegranate reduction sauce. The creative concoctions poured at the slick marble bar include whiskey mixed with apple and lemon juice or tequila with celery juice and lime.

121 Soquel Ave., Santa Cruz, CA, 95060, USA
831-423–7427
Known For
  • Excellent burgers and fries
  • Crab appetizers
  • Dark-chocolate soufflé and other tasty desserts
Restaurant Details
Closed Sun.–Tues.

Something incorrect in this review?

Shadowbrook

$$$

To get to this romantic spot overlooking Soquel Creek, you can take a cable car or walk the stairs down a steep, fern-lined bank beside a running waterfall. Dining room options include the rooftop Redwood Room, the wood-paneled Wine Cellar, the creek-side, glass-enclosed Greenhouse, the Fireplace Room, and the airy Garden Room.

1750 Wharf Rd., Capitola, CA, 95010, USA
831-475–1511
Known For
  • Romantic creek-side setting
  • Prime rib and grilled seafood
  • Local special-occasion favorite for nearly 70 years

Something incorrect in this review?

Tarpy's Roadhouse

$$$

Fun, dressed-up American favorites—a little something for everyone—are served in this renovated early-1900s stone farmhouse several miles east of town. The kitchen cranks out everything from Cajun-spiced prawns to meat loaf with marsala-mushroom gravy to grilled ribs and steaks.

2999 Monterey–Salinas Hwy., Monterey, CA, 93940, USA
831-647–1444
Known For
  • American comfort food with a California twist
  • Rustic dining near an indoor fireplace or out in a garden courtyard
  • Generous portions

Something incorrect in this review?

Vesuvio

$$$

Chef and restaurateur Rich Pèpe heats up the night with this lively trattoria downstairs and swinging rooftop terrace, the Star Bar. Pèpe's elegant take on traditional Italian cuisine yields dishes such as risotto made with local seafood, spicy Calabrian sausage, and lobster reduction sauce, crab ravioli, and velvety limoncello mousse cake.

6th and Junipero Aves., Carmel, CA, USA
831-625–1766
Known For
  • Traditional cuisine of Campania, Italy
  • Two bars with pizzas and small plates
  • Live music on rooftop terrace in summer
Restaurant Details
No lunch
Cash not accepted

Something incorrect in this review?

Wild Fish

$$$

Inventive dishes—made with 100% organic and locally sourced ingredients—live music, and a friendly staff are among the reasons why this intimate, ocean-to-table eatery is packed on weekends. Everything is fresh as it gets, from fish-and-chips, Monterey Bay bouillabaisse, and whole roasted fish of the day to local greens with spicy vinaigrette.

545 Lighthouse Ave., Pacific Grove, CA, 93950, USA
831-373–8523
Known For
  • Cured house-smoked sablefish
  • Jazz quartet on Friday and Saturday nights
  • Smoked fish chowder

Something incorrect in this review?